2 ms·
Maybe our positions aren't as far apart as I thought, but I do think you're stretching some of Raymond's quotes. Also not every open source pioneer sees things
by simonh 8y ago
Maybe our positions aren't as far apart as I thought, but I do think you're stretching some of Raymond's quotes. Also not every open source pioneer sees things the same way. Bruce Perens is on record saying in his opinion forking is a fundemantal part of open source and healthy for the ecosystem, and has no sympathy for companies unable to make money off the back of it -
https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/03/12/aws_elasticsearch_distro/ https://www.theregister.co.uk/2019/03/12/aws_elasticsearch_d...
- eesmith 8y agoJust to check - you think that Bruce Perens, author of the Debian Social Contract, didn't think there was an existing, albeit ill-defined, implicit and non-universal, social contract for free software projects before he wrote that document? My comments here concern the advocacy from when open source was new, so pointing to Perens' comment from a few days ago doesn't provide insight to what he thought 20 years previous. I'm sure if you ask Raymond about forks now, his answer would be different than it was in 1998. My observation is that his analysis then was flawed because it made a specific prediction about preventing forking. Things can be influential even if flawed, so confirming that there is a flaw doesn't mean it wasn't influential.