8 ms·
The issue is impacting all users who forgot their password, use Gmail (not sure about other clients) and don’t notice the hidden messages being at the bottom (i
by ggm 8y ago
The issue is impacting all users who forgot their password, use Gmail (not sure about other clients) and don’t notice the hidden messages being at the bottom (it’s really hard to spot).
So the "bug" is collapsed message/sort/thread view?
Feels like this is about as un-bug-like as you can get. Adding the unique Subject: line feels like the right fix (in you) rather than shout at google "you have a bug"
- pjc50 8y agoThe argument is that collapsed view should show the most recent message and collapse the older ones, not the other way round.
- mrlala 8y agoBut it doesn't really know which individual messages inside you have read. So collapsing everything but the most recent one is dangerous because that is a real risk of missing messages. The current way yeah you might have to see where the conversation left off- but it's the safest to not hide something from the user.
- yellowapple 8y agoGmail does know which messages in the thread you've already read, though; it'll leave the unread messages uncollapsed, but the ones that were already read will be collapsed. The problem is that the first message is also uncollapsed, so the user has to know to scroll to the bottom.
- mannykannot 8y agoI am quite surprised by this response, and even more that there are several saying the same thing. > So the "bug" is collapsed message/sort/thread view? No - the bug is that new messages were being hidden because they were mischaracterized as redundant. I quickly disabled Google's 'conversations' feature (or whatever they call it), when it was first introduced, because it did not seem to be doing a good job, but did not think about its wider implications. I probably should not be surprised about these reactions, as I have had experience with fellow developers who insist that what is manifestly a bug is not one because it is "working as designed", or because there is an undocumented workaround to the undocumented problem.
- mattmanser 8y agoIt does a great job, apart from this, it's a really annoying thing that I have no idea why they've done it.