2 ms·
Meanwhile, even though the _only_ user-tracking we do where I work is Google Analytics (no advertising features) (and you say your lawyers say you don't need co
by jrochkind1 8y ago
Meanwhile, even though the _only_ user-tracking we do where I work is Google Analytics (no advertising features) (and you say your lawyers say you don't need consent for that) -- the official word on high where I work is all our websites need the stupid "i consent to cookies" banner if we use cookies.
So, yeah, it's a mess. These "extra" warnings are contributing to user fatigue, I agree with troy hunt that users are just gonna ignore them all. I also understand why a small organization can say "Well, I don't really understand if we need it or not, the lowest risk thing to do is just to supply it." And there's no law _preventing_ you from supplying an unnecessary pointless cookie warning banner...
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- FridgeSeal 8y agoThat’s more the fault of the higher ups for not understanding the law correctly, which really, is on them because the EU went to quite a bit of length to make the document readable and if execs/managers aren’t smart enough to know the difference between necessary and tracking cookies on their own site, then that’s really their own fault.
- droithomme 8y ago> the EU went to quite a bit of length to make the document readable It's 88 pages of legalese consisting of 99 articles distributed over 13 chapters. It also has dozens of footnotes which incorporate thousands of pages of other laws by reference. > and if execs/managers aren’t smart enough Clearly I am too stupid to operate a business and have reading comprehension problems. Thanks for letting me know.
- flukus 8y ago> Meanwhile, even though the _only_ user-tracking we do where I work is Google Analytics (no advertising features) (and you say your lawyers say you don't need consent for that) -- the official word on high where I work is all our websites need the stupid "i consent to cookies" banner if we use cookies. Google analytics feeds tracking data to google for advertising purposes and tracks you across sites, it's exactly the sort of crap the cookie warning was meant to stop. > These "extra" warnings are contributing to user fatigue Your need for analytics is contributing to user fatigue. > I agree with troy hunt that users are just gonna ignore them all So do websites putting up these silly warnings, do you actually wait for people to accept before they get their tracking cookie?
- lmkg 8y ago> Google analytics feeds tracking data to google for advertising purposes and tracks you across sites That is why GP said "(no advertising features)." That is the name of the feature in GA that does that, and it can be disabled.
- Grumbledour 8y agoHowever, google is still a third party and I would argue this is not legal, as is using google maps or other external entities known to employ excessive tracking unless you have special data protection contracts with said entity. But I also understand the law, that anonymous user statistics are just fine and don't need consent as long as you retain the data yourself and of course mention it in your privacy policy. Though you might still be obligated to respect "do not track" and adding an opt-out setting.