4 ms·
Of course the President can just tell the FAA what to do. I understand that. The question is how the public should have been informed by the event. Dan Elwell,
by dragontamer 8y ago
Of course the President can just tell the FAA what to do. I understand that.
The question is how the public should have been informed by the event. Dan Elwell, the acting director of the FAA, is both a military and commercial pilot. If he made the announcement, it would have carried far more weight than Trump (who likely doesn't know much about airplanes).
- numbsafari 8y agos/likely/clearly/
- caprese 8y agoThe President of the United States made the announcement. Thats what is being written in the history books. It carries weight regardless of who is in office. In a tiny little footnote on wikipedia it will mention how disturbed citizens of California got the Secretary of Transportation or the FAA to reissue the same order because "orange man bad". You might be led to think I'm being "unsubstantive" but this is how the EO for gold confiscation is recorded (but the Secretary of the Treasury merely reissued it after a court challenge), as well as the EO for Japanese interment camps are recorded.
- bluesroo 8y agoThat would have only carried weight for those who know who Dan Elwell is. He carries no weight with me other than apparently being "acting director of the FAA". The president, even if he's disliked by many, carries much more weight for the average person.
- dragontamer 8y agoThere are plenty of proper ways to do things. Ex: Trump could have said that the acting director of the FAA has news about the MAX 8.
- notahacker 8y agoThe public don't need to know who Dan Elwell is, they need to know that the decision to take a very disruptive emergency safety precaution has been taken by the relevant safety body after evaluating the currently-known relevant information. (The people who actually execute the grounding of the Max know who he is anyway) I don't actually think Trump is doing anything wrong in trying to take responsibility for the action, and suspect the decision was reached through appropriate channels rather than by him reading something by a pilot on Twitter, but having a president known for more being capricious than his understanding of aviation safety as the figurehead behind the decision does make it look less like a reasoned decision to the average person, especially if they have strong anti-Trump priors.
- ryantruran 8y agoThere is no question that the acting director of the FAA would be more knowledgeable about airplanes than Trump. While technical individuals are needed during the investigation, I don't believe that this decision warrants a full-on root cause analysis prior to making the decision to ground the planes. The FAA's Primary Mission is to ensure the safety of civil aviation, and from a safety stance, if the acting director is incorrect, and another plane was to go down, hundreds of people would likely be killed.
- Const-me 8y ago> Trump (who likely doesn't know much about airplanes) Trump owned an airline with a fleet of 17 Boeings. He also used 2 large Boeings as private jets. Very likely he knows a thing or 2 about airplanes.
- jonnycoder 8y agoYou have it wrong. Orange Man Bad! I predicted two days ago that this would turn into a shit storm of hysteria, justified or not. The President exerting his authority is similar in that sometimes these events turn too emotional and fearful. He made the right call for that sake.
- whyaduck 8y agoI'd trust his assessment of an aircraft's airworthiness as far as I'd trust his assessment of structural stability of a skyscraper.
- rsynnott 8y agoI own quite a nice spider plant. Surprisingly, I am not a botanist.
- Const-me 8y agoYou likely know about spider plants much more than average person who doesn't have any of them.
- mywittyname 8y ago> Dan Elwell, the acting director of the FAA, is both a military and commercial pilot. Also important: he's a lobbiest for the airline industry. It made the news when he was confirmed because of his ties to the industry. He is the Ajit Pai or Betsy DeVos of the FAA.
- tzs 8y ago> He is the Ajit Pai or Betsy DeVos of the FAA. Why not the Tom Wheeler of the FAA? That seems to be a closer fit to the kind of industry ties he has had then either Pai or DeVos. Pai's industry ties was as a lawyer for Verizon, whereas Wheeler's were as head of first the cable trade association and later the wireless trade association, and having been involved in several telecom companies. That seems a much closer match to Elwell, who was VP of a major aerospace trade association and a pilot and an airline executive.
- mywittyname 8y agoPeople here know Ajit Pai and DeVos as they are constantly in the news. I've never heard of Tom Wheeler, so I wouldn't think to use his name.
- briandear 8y agoObama's last FAA director wasn't even a pilot. He had a degree in political science. At least Elwell has actually flown airplanes -- including 16 years flying airliners for American. He also has combat aviation experience. Elwell is far more competent than Michael Heurta. Huerta's background was in politics, working for New York City and Later the Port of San Francisco. No flight experience, no airline experience, no general aviation experience. People criticized Trump for putting a non-scientist at the head of the Department of Energy, however, where is the criticism of Obama for putting a non-pilot as the head of the FAA? When Trump does something wrong, sure, criticize him, but Elwell is an experienced, relevant choice to head the FAA -- especially compared to Huerta. Reducing Elwell to "Lobbyist" is silly, if one actually looks at his background.