9 ms·
The blog comment is absolutely correct. I distribute open source software. I give a big advantage to those willing to pay me through a support contract. And a
by eesmith 8y ago
The blog comment is absolutely correct.
I distribute open source software. I give a big advantage to those willing to pay me through a support contract.
And as for the (unwritten) "promise the maintainer made", that social contract goes both ways. If that exists, then what of the promise that users will support the maintainer?
Remember esr's hyping of the "gift culture" to open source? In practice it's balderdash. Or as Zed Shaw puts it:
> There was sort of like this unwritten contract in open source that we had; the unwritten contract with corporations was if you wrote open source that they were using, you got some sort of job, or consulting fees, or at least some respect so that way you could find jobs.
> ... I started to realize that “No, that contract has completely been rewritten. It’s totally different now. If you write open source, you’re not gonna get a job”, and now what’s been happening - and part of my tweet storm and whatnot about open source - is that it’s gone the opposite direction, where what I see is sort of like almost direct action to prevent open source developers from making money…
Quoted from https://changelog.com/podcast/300 https://changelog.com/podcast/300 .
- pjmlp 8y agoThere was also the unwritten contract that users of open source would support their developers. Instead, every time someone posts something where they are trying to make a living out of their open source dream, there is a pile of posts complaining about having to pay even 0.01 to them, posting free alternatives with half of the features, or forking the project. Even on a place like HN, which was supposed to be about creating companies in first place.
- weego 8y agoWhat's the point of living in an artifical bubble leading people down the wrong path? Building software doesn't guarantee that it's worth anything to anyone else. If it is and is meaningfully better than free alternatives they will pay. If not then that's literally the life of an 'entrepreneur'. Similarly with OSS, no one de facto deserves funding just because they maintain open source software, popular or not. And if you think that companies will support you and play ball with your own whims then you're living in a fantasy world. The crux is the naivety of the people involved. If you don't like that CompanyX will use or fork your code with no financial contributions then don't use those licenses and roll the dice to see how that works out for you like any other business. Those freedoms they grant you are granted to everyone whether a one man band or a global enterprise. If you want to play pick and choose then you're using the wrong definition of 'free'
- ThrowawayR2 8y ago> There was also the unwritten contract that users of open source would support their developers. Doesn't match my recollection. Back when FOSS was a rising star, the rallying cry was "free as in beer and free as in speech". No suggestion of an unwritten contract was there and it was amply clear that the vast majority who were piling on to FOSS were infinitely more interested in the free as in beer part than the other. FOSS created the widespread belief that software and digital information should be gratis; that's the only unwritten contract.
- pjmlp 8y agoFree beer only works if there is actually any beer available. Someone needs to produce wheat and brew it.
- ThrowawayR2 8y agoSure, but the vast majority using the code don't care and never will. The FOSS movement built its momentum by attracting freeloaders intentionally; turning around a couple decades later and saying to them "but you have to support the developers too; pay up" is doomed to failure. Moreover, it was clear that what we're seeing today was an inevitable outcome from the beginning, much as the true believers denied it at the time.
- simonh 8y agoThere is no ‘promise that users will support the maintainer’ and never has been. Open source was originally about developers sharing code with each other and jointly contributing to it, to make their lives easier. Look at all the original GNU projects, they’re almost entirely developer tools, shared infrastructure and games. The core right of open source is for users to modify the code, because in the GOL no distinction is made between users and developers, they are the same. The fact that some people have been able to build companies on open source software is essentially a happy coincidence. That outcome wasn’t considered or deliberately provided for in the licences or by the movement. If it hadn’t been possible at all, the movement would have been fine with that. Now that we have decades and generations growing up with commercialised open source, people are thinking that this was by design and something is wrong if open source isn’t commercialisable in this way or that. No. Nothing is wrong. Commercialisation is occasionally an incidental side effect. It is not the point.
- brennebeck 8y ago>There is no ‘promise that users will support the maintainer’ and never has been. Certainly not officially... >Open source was originally about developers sharing code with each other and jointly contributing to it, to make their lives easier. Look at all the original GNU projects, they’re almost entirely developer tools, shared infrastructure and games. The core right of open source is for users to modify the code, because in the GOL no distinction is made between users and developers, they are the same. I would argue that _is_ the promise of supporting the maintainer ;)
- simonh 8y agoIt's supporting the software. The OGL in particular is a manifesto of user's rights over the software they run on their machines and that's all.
- dotandimet 8y agoYou seem to be mixing up GNU's GPL (GNU Public License) with the OGL (Open Gaming License) from Wizards of the Coast. Roleplayer?
- 0815test 8y ago> No, that contract has completely been rewritten. It’s totally different now. If you write open source, you’re not gonna get a job Writing popular OSS software (e.g. via github/gitlab) is still one of the best ways to attract the attention of employers. The bottleneck is not "writing software" in the abstract, it's support - which also includes maintenance and addressing custom feature requests. And there's nothing wrong with requesting that support be paid for, nor is this per se incompatible with open source licensing. So, I'd say that ESR's argument still succeeds. People just seem to want things from OSS (or even "open core") development models that would be far from feasible with plain-old proprietary development - such as economic returns in the billion dollar range. This is quite silly, in my view - if the "problem" with FLOSS is that we aren't getting that kind of money from it, that just means that there's not much to complain about.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y agoIt may not be incompatible per-se, but it does create a perverse incentive to make the open version of the product harder to work with.