3 ms·
> To my knowledge, the link is only invalidated if the person actually downloads the file. I've used one-time-link services sometimes, and posting the link to
by JoshTriplett 8y ago
> To my knowledge, the link is only invalidated if the person actually downloads the file.
I've used one-time-link services sometimes, and posting the link to Slack causes Slack to make an HTTP fetch looking for metadata, which then invalidates the link.
- regecks 8y agoThe easy solution is for the link to lead to an interstitial that shows "do you want to view the content? It will be the only time you can do so.", and make the underlying HTTP resource unpredictable (e.g. different ID to the link) so that it cannot be directly addressed. It's a very common and easy to anticipate issue, I'm surprised that there are any one-time-link services left that suffer from it.
- bradknowles 8y agoWhich is why you put a trivial password on the file, which isn't included as part of the link. Then, any automated system which sees the link cannot accidentally cause the file to be "downloaded" which would cause the link to be invalidated. They can see the link itself, but they don't have the password, therefore they can't download the content to scan it. I have used onetimesecret.com a number of times in this way.