3 ms·
> There was nothing stopping Mozilla from making a “Firefox phone” and having a fully integrated experience. Well they did try and failed to execute. The whole
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
> There was nothing stopping Mozilla from making a “Firefox phone” and having a fully integrated experience. Well they did try and failed to execute.
The whole issue is that you shouldn't have to succeed in the phone market before you can operate an app store. Tying the phone to a specific app store is the problem. "Integrated experience" is the argument Microsoft failed to convince with when it tied Internet Explorer to Windows.
> If app makers don’t think the trade off is worth it, they are free to only target the other 80% of the phone market.
In other words, Apple has a monopoly over 20% of the app customers, in the same way that Charter may have a broadband monopoly in 20% of the country even if there are other providers in the other 80%.
Notice that this isn't the same thing as saying that Walmart has a monopoly over its own shelf space, because customers can trivially switch from Walmart to Amazon or vice versa at any time but to buy a $1 app from Amazon or Google Play instead of Apple you would first have to replace your $1000 phone. To reach the same position as Walmart, the issue isn't that they control what's in their own store, it's that there are no competing iOS app stores.
Moreover, the problem with the App Store isn't just that Apple takes 30%, it's that they can reject your app for entirely opaque reasons without recourse, explicitly including because it competes with one of theirs.
- scarface74 8y agoIn other words, Apple has a monopoly over 20% of the app customers, in the same way that Charter may have a broadband monopoly in 20% of the country even if there are other providers in the other 80%. I can walk into any mobile store and have a choice between dozens of phones. Most people can’t choose their homes internet service provider. Notice that this isn't the same thing as saying that Walmart has a monopoly over its own shelf space, because customers can trivially switch from Walmart to Amazon or vice versa at any time but to buy a $1 app from Amazon or Google Play instead of Apple you would first have to replace your $1000 phone. To reach the same position as Walmart, the issue isn't that they control what's in their own store, it's that there are no competing iOS app stores. People can choose whether they want to spend money on an iPhone or an Android phone knowing the trade offs just like people can choose whether to buy an Xbox or PS4. it's that they can reject your app for entirely opaque reasons without recourse, explicitly including because it competes with one of theirs. Seeing that there are competing products for everything that Apple sells, this is a boogeymen that doesn’t happen anymore than it happens for the console makers. You do realize that no software can be sold for consoles without the approval of the console makers - including physical sells.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> I can walk into any mobile store and have a choice between dozens of phones. Most people can’t choose their homes internet service provider. No, but they can choose their home, which is the relevant analog. If you don't like Charter, just move to another city. If you don't like the Apple App Store, just buy another phone. If the thing you have to buy to get a choice costs 1000 times more than the thing you're choosing, it's not a real choice. > People can choose whether they want to spend money on an iPhone or an Android phone knowing the trade offs just like people can choose whether to buy an Xbox or PS4. "People can choose whether they want to spend money on a house in Charter's service area or Comcast's service area knowing the trade offs..." And it being no different for consoles only means that the same rules should apply there as well. > Seeing that there are competing products for everything that Apple sells What is the competition for Safari then? Notice that "Firefox" on iOS isn't even real Firefox because Apple requires it to use Safari's engine internally. Also, the App Store is an app.
- scarface74 8y agoNo, but they can choose their home, which is the relevant analog. If you don't like Charter, just move to another city. If you don't like the Apple App Store, just buy another phone. Yes it was one of the deciding factors when I bought my house was the internet service available. But if I don’t like Apples policies it’s a lot easier to buy another $500 phone than a $400K house. What is the competition for Safari then?” Opera Mini.... Also, the App Store is an app. Apple “sells” the App Store?