3 ms·
You're right that by modern standards, the man looks like a quack. But by historical standards, he moved the field of psychology towards science. While other "p
by dragontamer 8y ago
You're right that by modern standards, the man looks like a quack. But by historical standards, he moved the field of psychology towards science. While other "psychologists" were still measuring brain dimensions (see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phrenology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Phrenology), Freud was at least conducting interviews, studying patients, and writing up case-studies.
The actual scientists who employed the scientific method (Pavalov, Skinner, etc. etc.) would enter the field decades after Freud. For better or worse, the best psychologist in the 1890s was Freud. Since Freud has huge impact on the field of Psychology, he's important to study (especially with regards to "movie psychology": the commonly-believed false-psychology propagated by fiction).
In any case, the article draws "Willpower's" historical basis to the rough time period immediately before Freud (the 1850s). That alone is sufficient to bring suspicion to our understanding of "Willpower".