5 ms·
The problem comes from political views being dressed up as scientific. There's no question that there are biological differences caused by e.g. hormone levels b
by acdha 8y ago
The problem comes from political views being dressed up as scientific. There's no question that there are biological differences caused by e.g. hormone levels but that hasn't been linked to high-level cognitive skills the same way, say, testosterone levels correlate with muscle development (this also raises the question of the degree of overlap between populations). This is especially complicated in humans because the brain is famously plastic and high-level cognitive skills represent years of practice so even if you did find, say, a difference in the size of a brain region you would still want to study whether that's innate or simply reflecting that people who do something a lot develop capacity for it. Similarly, most higher-level tasks combine multiple skills, often in different combinations, so it's really hard to try to go from a low-level measurement to explaining performance on something high level.
The neuroscientists I used to support were very quick to acknowledge that innate effects were possible but that they hadn't been linked to anything high level and were in all likelihood weak because if there was a strong effect so many decades of studies looking for them would have found something.
- deogeo 8y agoThen isn't https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-00677-x https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-019-00677-x also 'dressing up political views as scientific'? But that stirs far less controversy. At the very least, no-one ever got fired for claiming there are no differences.
- acdha 8y ago> But that stirs far less controversy. There's a difference between claiming that there are no difference and critically examining specific claims to see how well supported they are by the scientific evidence. The book review you linked to appears to fall in that tradition of critically examining claims and looking at sources of systemic error. > At the very least, no-one ever got fired for claiming there are no differences. Nobody has been fired for relevant scientifically-supported claims, either. What has happened is that some guys have spouted off outside of their areas of competency and tried to avoid the consequences by handwaving something about engaging in science. Science is a tool for becoming less-wrong over time, not a get-out-of-jail-free card.
- deogeo 8y agoYet there are no consequences to avoid when people 'spout off outside their area of competency' and claim everyone is equal. Look at e.g. Damore's memo. It was relevant and cited peer reviewed research in support of its claims. Whether those claims were true is another matter, but they were "scientifically supported" by any sensible standard. Yet he was fired, while all the people claiming the exact opposite, even when they did not cite any research, and just as much "outside their areas of competency", were not. In that sense, you're very much correct - if you say something sufficiently unpopular, no matter how well scientifically supported, science won't act as a get-out-of-jail-free card, and won't save you from the backlash. At best it might provide a Nobel prize you can sell for cash when things get dire.
- acdha 8y agoHaving read Damore’s memo, I would not describe it that way. He was spouting off outside of his area of competency or job and in particular never established a link between the few cited papers and his claims. Linking a study about toy preferences in monkeys (no matter its merits) is a long way from supporting the claim that Google’s management stats were just reflecting a shortage of qualified people.
- stcredzero 8y agoHaving read Damore’s memo, I would not describe it that way. Odd, but I saw videos of Google and YouTube execs soon afterwards talking at conferences saying some of the same things that were somehow so terrible in the Damore memo. In particular, they stated that they were doing about as well as the education pipeline could allow, and they also speculated that there might be changes to the work environment which could make jobs more desirable to women. Linking a study about toy preferences in monkeys (no matter its merits) is a long way from supporting the claim that Google’s management stats were just reflecting a shortage of qualified people. That hardly strikes me as an intellectually robust summary of the memo.
- acdha 8y ago
- pmarreck 8y agoWhat if it had nothing to do with brain effects but something to do with raw interest in a thing? I have serious doubts that my interests were given to me socially. I have always liked the color and flavor orange, I have always liked chocolate (one of my best friends does not), I have always wanted to take things apart to figure out how they worked... the latter led more or less "naturally" to programming (especially after taking my first programming class and realizing I LOVED it). What if it turned out that the "urge to take things apart and learn how they worked", at some very low level, was more of a male thing? Why would that be so bad? That doesn't mean that equivalently-interested women need be held back in any way/shape/form (because, duh, they shouldn't!)
- acdha 8y ago> What if it had nothing to do with brain effects but something to do with raw interest in a thing? Where does that raw interest come from? Humans are highly social creatures and children show signs of learning socially very early so it requires a great deal of care to distinguish between a correlation and the underlying cause. If something is social behaviour, that means that we can also question whether it's worth continuing. > What if it turned out that the "urge to take things apart and learn how they worked", at some very low level, was more of a male thing? Why would that be so bad? That doesn't mean that equivalently-interested women need be held back in any way/shape/form (because, duh, they shouldn't!) The problem is that the latter part is really hard to actually deliver: historically that meant that girls were actively discouraged or prevented from being interested in things which are identified as male but even without overt prevention social pressure is a real problem — maybe nobody tells someone directly “you can't do this” but if the image of programming is “you'd be the only girl” or the widespread “only nerdy boys like this” trope that's going to have an impact, and one which will probably start well before anyone is, say, picking a major in college. It doesn't even need to be conscious — maybe nobody actually thinks negatively but they just assumed that, say, a bright high school student would be more interested in biology than math or CS and never really even suggested the latter. Maybe at some point they give up after being asked again why they're doing something associated with the other gender, which is tiring even if it's not intended to be mean. Those social factors are all around us and the only thing which seems to work is actively correcting against them so that every kid has as wide a range of opportunities open to them.