3 ms·
It is possible to respond to someone while agreeing with them. But allow me to disagree with your conclusion. The problem isn't predatory pricing, but the netw
by AnthonyMouse 8y ago
It is possible to respond to someone while agreeing with them.
But allow me to disagree with your conclusion. The problem isn't predatory pricing, but the network effects problem is still a problem.
Now, granted, the problem is as much created by the government as anything. The law (CFAA, DMCA) makes it so that people can't create a Facebook "client" without Facebook's permission.
If they could, suddenly you've got a bunch of clients that consolidate many social networks into one interface, which makes it easier for users to switch to others. If Facebook is doing something you don't like, you install another back end to your client and transparently use that service with any friends who also have it. The more people Facebook offends, the more users they lose, without any specific other service ever having to reach some critical mass before most people can stop using Facebook.
That could be brought about by removing laws rather than adding them (though you could also pass new legislation to the same effect), but in either case it does require a piece of legislation to be passed to bring it about.
- scarface74 8y agoThe only way that you could make another Facebook client is by allowing third parties to access the social graph. Then you get Cambridge Analytics. When you give a third party access to “your” data with respect to your friends, they also have access to my data that I never gave them permission for.
- AnthonyMouse 8y agoMaking a third party client doesn't require any third party entity to access the data, only third party software -- which it already does. If your friend accesses Facebook via Firefox, Firefox inherently has that data. So does the operating system, the TLS library the browser uses, etc. But it never has to leave your friend's device, and neither would it need to with some different client.
- scarface74 8y agoSo how do we trust third party software not to be collecting data and sending it back? How does Facebook give access to the customer’s information and ensure that the third party doesn’t abuse it? My browser doesn’t have access to scrape all of my Facebook information and all of my friends FB information.
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> So how do we trust third party software not to be collecting data and sending it back? How do we trust that Chrome or Windows isn't currently? > How does Facebook give access to the customer’s information and ensure that the third party doesn’t abuse it? It's the customer giving the software access to the data. Facebook has no more to do with it than gmail has to do with whether you use Thunderbird or Outlook. > My browser doesn’t have access to scrape all of my Facebook information and all of my friends FB information. Neither would this need to. It has your Facebook credentials and accesses Facebook as you. No special rights, just the ability to do use Facebook in a consolidated interface without ending up in court. It couldn't do anything a malicious browser couldn't do with your Facebook cookie.
- scarface74 8y agoHave you forgotten what happened with Cambridge Analytica? A “Facebook cookie” doesn’t have all of the information to all my friends information
- AnthonyMouse 8y ago> Have you forgotten what happened with Cambridge Analytica? That was Facebook giving a third party everyone's information without consent. This is your friends having the information you shared with your friends. > A “Facebook cookie” doesn’t have all of the information to all my friends information It allows you to get all of the information that your account has access to on Facebook, which is all such a client would need.
- 8y ago