3 ms·
My problem with the concept of willpower is twofold. First, it has a distinctly moral component to it. The implication is that you have failed as a person if
by rootusrootus 8y ago
My problem with the concept of willpower is twofold.
First, it has a distinctly moral component to it. The implication is that you have failed as a person if you lack willpower. We discuss willpower as if our minds are purely rational things, which they most assuredly are not.
Second, it does not recognize the asymmetry of arguing with yourself. Especially with things like diet or addiction, your mind will simply remake the playing field to suit itself, and win. There is a reason 99% of everyone who diets to lose weight has failed at the five year point. The only way to succeed is to introduce a mental disorder: OCD.
- dragontamer 8y agoIts far simpler than that! For the proper scientist, there is only one question with regards to Willpower: Can you design an experiment which demonstrates the concept of willpower? There are "concepts" of Willpower that people believe: does "Willpower" run out when you keep using it? Or does "Willpower" get stronger the more you exercise it? Or is Willpower just completely wrong and completely a red herring? That's how the field of Psychology ACTUALLY advances: with people performing experiments on hundreds of people, to determine fundamental facts of how the human brain / human behavior works. The first two questions ("exhaustion of willpower" and "willpower exercise") can potentially be experimented. I'm wondering if any studied Psychologist knows of any experiments which can answer those questions. --------- Without experiments, the field of Psychology death-spirals into pseudoscience. It is EXPERIMENTS that ground us back into reality (Pavalov's Dog. Skinner's box. Etc. etc.) That's my lesson from Psychology class. Operant Conditioning exists and is 100% reproducible. Slot Machines and Loot Boxes are designed to follow Skinner's experiments on conditioning. Perhaps we can define "Scientific Willpower" as the (theorized) ability to resist conditioning, and develop experiments in that direction. I mean, people CAN quit slot machines, and give up on video-game loot boxes eventually. Why? What causes people to leave the Skinner-box? Is it an internal-force (ie: "Willpower")? Or is it an external stimulus? Skinner's experiments only studied the addiction-part of the cycle, it seems like the "quitting" part is still an open question.