6 ms·
I am not sanguine on the idea, but the marketing for the idea is beyond terrible. The IDL is a leaky abstraction because the most salient features of drivers l
by patio11 16y ago
I am not sanguine on the idea, but the marketing for the idea is beyond terrible. The IDL is a leaky abstraction because the most salient features of drivers licenses are a) you have to apply to the government to get one, b) the government can take yours away with as much ease as they can do anything else, and c) if you lose your license, you will be denied the ability to use one or more critical goods/services (driving).
That is what your mother thinks of when she hears Driver's License. Why on earth would that be the branding you pick for OpenID or federated authentication? You are practically trolling your own idea at that point!
Observe the kinds of things people are going to say about any federated identity scheme which you call a License:
"Jeff Atwood thinks the government should be able to take away your Facebook account! He's fascist!" "I didn't say that!"
"Jeff Atwood thinks your mom shouldn't be allowed on the Internet until she stops calling it 'the Googles'! He's an elitist bastard!" "I didn't say that!"
"Jeff Atwood thinks that if you get kicked off a WoW server you should lose your Gmail account. He's in bed with corporate interests!" "I didn't say that!"
- drats 16y agoI agree he's not selling it properly, but I would also say it's not actually that different to everything coming back to my email inbox and being remembered by my browser either. For me it's not a problem, perhaps for admins it is, which reminds me of the incessant caterwauling we used to have about "the spam problem" (which was often a mask for the micropayments movement). And people should reach for their gun when they hear people blabbering about ID centralisation, that's a good reaction. And considering there is a happy-go-lucky Belgian linking it to the government in the comments, I'd say they are right in some sense, it will embolden those who want the government to control everything on the Internet.
- wazoox 16y agoThat, and the concept of the driver's license as the definitive ID document is quasi exclusively and strongly connoted as a funny US peculiarity.
- arethuza 16y agoI'm in the UK and my driver's license is the only form of "official" ID I normally carry. Much to my delight, we canceled the silly project to issue government ID cards.
- rbanffy 16y agoWho issued your driver's license?
- rmc 16y agoThe UK Government
- arethuza 16y agoBut not everyone had a drivers license or a passport - so they wanted everyone to have a separate ID card. Generally, having a formal ID has only been required in the UK during dire emergencies (i.e. World Wars) and contrary to what the government of the time thought we are not in the middle of such a crisis.
- rbanffy 16y agoThe point is not the government issuing you an ID. The problem comes when it require you to carry it at all times.
- kleiba 16y agoEvery German older than 16 is required by law to have an ID card or passport. As of November 2010, ID cards carry RFID chips with the same data that's written on the card plus an optional fingerprint. Passports have had the chip for a while already, but the fingerprint is mandatory there. Driver's licenses are not considered a valid means of identification outside traffic.
- masklinn 16y agoLikewise in France, except as far as I know there are no rfid chips in the national id card (yet anyway). And in belgium (where the ID card is the size of a credit card and has a small chip, I don't know if it has an RFID chip)
- rmc 16y agoPerhaps a more accurate metaphore would be "Internet Passport". Government's can't take it away and it has no real entitlements. However Jeff Atwood is from the USA which has a strangley low number of passport holders. Perhaps they are used to using a driving licence instead of passport as general ID.
- jaywalker 16y agoWhy we can't just call it "Internet Identity?"
- ZoFreX 16y agoI imagine this is why Microsoft's Live ID was originally called Passport.
- brazzy 16y agoPerhaps they are used to using a driving licence instead of passport as general ID. No perhaps about it. It seems to the average American, the word "drivers license" evokes "proof of identity" first and "proof of ability to drive a car" second, because they're using theirs as a general ID more often than for its original purpose. It gets even funnier when American companies operate abroad and require "two photo IDs" in countries where everyone has a government-provided ID card.
- brown9-2 16y agoIt seems to the average American, the word "drivers license" evokes "proof of identity" first and "proof of ability to drive a car" second, because they're using theirs as a general ID more often than for its original purpose. This is because the idea of a National ID Card is for some strange reason (strange to this American, I mean) seen as an evil thing by the general public here.
- akmiller 16y agoWhat the hell is a social security card if not a national ID card. Unique number assigned to each american citizen and you are forced to have it.
- drdaeman 16y agoI believe the term "license" itself is completely inappropriate for personal identities.
- grandpa 16y agoAnd d) you have to take a test to get one.
- drdaeman 16y agoIf that's the case, our tech support team (I work for an ISP) would wholeheartedly welcome those Internet User's Licenses. Obviously, just kidding.
- mcantor 16y agoFTA: Now, I don't literally mean a driver's license. I'm using this term figuratively to mean online credentials that I can re-use in more than one place on the internet.
- lmkg 16y agoPersonally, the idea I have in my mind of a (US) driver's license is a universally-accepted form of ID that anyone can get. The facts that it has a test, or that it can be revoked, or that some people don't have one, don't actually register in my head until someone points it out. If it weren't in the name, I wouldn't even connect it with driving. Furthermore, it's the only abstraction I have in my head for a universal ID. Passport's aren't universal (at least in the US) because they're bigger and therefore less convenient, and international travel is somewhat rare. We don't have a universal government-issued ID that's just an ID, so the idea of a national ID card sounds scary and government-intrusive to me. A driver's license is literally the most innocuous and least threatening analogy to make. Until you point out the ways in which it doesn't work the way I think it works. When most people think of driver's licenses, do they really think government certification, or do they think universal ID? I would be honestly interested in the answer.
- alextgordon 16y agoPersonally, the idea I have in my mind of a (US) driver's license is a universally-accepted form of ID that anyone can get. Don't you have to take a test to obtain a licence? Here in the UK the test is relatively difficult and expensive, so not everybody has a licence. Passports are much cheaper, easier to obtain and don't come with age limits, so they are a more universal form of ID (though they are also bulky and hardly something you would carry around on you). When most people think of driver's licenses, do they really think government certification, or do they think universal ID? I would be honestly interested in the answer. When I think of driver's licences, I think of driving a car. Universal ID doesn't occur.
- masklinn 16y agoSee his next phrase.
- URSpider94 16y agoI agree with you that a driver's license is more a form of ID than a public safety credential, if you live in the USA. Why? -- You have to take a test to get it, but you do that when you are 16 or 17, and never again. In most states, the test is ridiculously easy. -- In an average year, you probably use it hundreds of times for its ID value (to buy beer at the grocery store or drinks at a bar, to cash a check, to check in for an airline flight), and (hopefully) zero times for the public safety function (showing it to a police officer after being pulled over). -- Outside of NYC, the fraction of people over the legal driving age who don't have a license has to be less than 10%