4 ms·
This is patently false. Google’s monopoly is on resources required to be a search competitor. It has a giant stash of patents related to search, and it also h
by zepto 8y ago
This is patently false.
Google’s monopoly is on resources required to be a search competitor. It has a giant stash of patents related to search, and it also has an enormous collection of historical data that can never be obtained by a new competitors. On top of that it continues to extract behavioral and structural data about both users and the web from things like analytics, Android, etc. with gigantic reach.
These are gigantic barriers to entry and Google created them.
Now it’s reasonable to argue that there they did nothing insidious or unfair in order to create them.
However just because they didn’t do anything evil to create the barriers to entry they now enjoy doesn’t mean they didn’t create them or that they now enjoy a monopoly position as a consequence.
- root_axis 8y ago> It has a giant stash of patents related to search Patents are not an antitrust violation. Breaking up google doesn't revoke their patents. > On top of that it continues to extract behavioral and structural data about both users and the web from things like analytics, Android, etc. with gigantic reach. Breaking up google doesn't mean all this insight disappears. We need better data privacy laws to address this. > These are gigantic barriers to entry and Google created them. You haven't described a barrier to entry, you've described a product that is so far ahead of the rest of the market that it's difficult to compete, but there is nothing preventing a competitor from giving it their best shot. If somehow a group of genius polymath programmers developed a superior search product, nothing about google's current business practices (besides brand awareness) would hinder their success.
- zepto 8y agoA barrier to entry is something a competitor cannot acquire. I have clearly described multiple of those. It’s not just difficult to compete. It is impossible for competitors to acquire the insight that Google has amassed, since it is based on historical data that is not available anymore. Breaking up google wouldn’t make this insight disappear, but the fact that you acknowledge it exists proves my point that barriers to entry are present. Your claim that I haven’t described a barrier to entry is therefore false based on the implications of your own statements. I am not arguing that the remedy should be the breakup of Google, and your complaints about that remedy are irrelevant to what I am saying, and do not refute the contention that Google is in a monopoly position. Nevertheless I am arguing that Google has critical resources that cannot be replicated by this mythical group of genius polymaths because they are now owned by Google exclusively, and that this is certainly a consequence of their market position, power and business practices. It is ridiculous to suggest that the only thing preventing this is ‘brand awareness’. It’s hard to believe you are serious about that.
- root_axis 8y ago> A barrier to entry is something a competitor cannot acquire. This is 100% incorrect. By that definition every company's private source code is a barrier to entry for their competitors. Clearly this is wrong. > It is impossible for competitors to acquire the insight that Google has amassed, since it is based on historical data that is not available anymore. I'm sorry but you are just plain wrong about what constitutes a barrier to entry. "The product is so advanced that nobody can compete" is not a barrier. "All you have to do" is produce a better product; just because that is hard does not make it a barrier. > I am arguing that Google has critical resources that cannot be replicated by this mythical group of genius polymaths because they are now owned by Google exclusively I am just going to repeat myself with emphasis since you don't seem to be understanding that patents are not an antitrust violation. I am going to repeat it again: patents are not an antitrust violation. If you want to discuss the ethics of software patents that's a different topic where I likely agree with you, but within the context of anti-competitive behavior owning patents does not qualify. By your logic I suppose you want to break up Tesla since they are a market leader with a massive patent-warchest. If not, why not? > it is ridiculous to suggest that the only thing preventing this is ‘brand awareness’. This is a misreading of what I wrote. I'll assume it wasn't deliberate. What I said was that if a group of engineers produced a better product, the only thing that would prevent their product from being successful is google's ubiquitous branding, there is nothing about google's business practices that would prevent a superior product from being successful. Your argument is that google is so advanced that nobody can produce a superior product, but even if thats true, producing a superior product is not anti-competitive.
- zepto 8y ago> This is 100% incorrect. By that definition every company's private source code is a barrier to entry for their competitors. Clearly this is wrong. Nope. In the case of source code, a competitor has just as much opportunity to solve the same problem in either the same way or a better way. In the case of data which is no longer available, there is no equivalent way to reproduce it. You either took advantage of it when it was available, or you never can. These are two different things. Google’s code may be replicable, but their data and access to data are not. You place "The product is so advanced that nobody can compete" in quote marks as if it’s what I’m saying, but in reality, nobody is saying this. It’s just a straw man that you can keep railing against, as if it’s what other people are saying. You can repeat your misunderstandings again and again with additional emphasis if you like.