5 ms·
All three. It also has to do with pilot training. The general idea is that there is an auto-trim system meant to stop the plane from stalling. But when it ge
by sandworm101 8y ago
All three. It also has to do with pilot training.
The general idea is that there is an auto-trim system meant to stop the plane from stalling. But when it gets bad data from a faulty sensor it tries to crash the aircraft (short version). Pilots, all pilots, are trained to recognize this and override the system, but this aircraft requires them to do some things slightly differently. Specifically, they have to shut down the system rather than manually work against it. Difficulties arise where there is a disconnect between what the pilots think is happening, what the systems think and tell them is happening, and what the aircraft is actually experiencing. So this is an interaction between an automated system (software) a potentially faulty sensor (hardware) and pilot training. It is a complex problem that will take a while to fully understand and solve.
- notfromhere 8y agoIt's a simple problem: don't dodge training requirements by falsely stating that there's no need to retrain pilots on this aircraft. These crashes happened because Boeing tried to market the plane as not requiring retraining in order to boost sales to airlines.
- SmellyGeekBoy 8y agoThis is a very succint explanation of what's happening here (in the Lion Air case, anyway). Not sure why you're being downvoted - perhaps the claim that this is a "complex problem".
- sandworm101 8y agoHN is slowly walking towards facebook culture. People up/down vote things they like or dislike, with the goal of disappearing opinions with which they even mildly disagree. Valid points and thoughtful discussion are increasingly unwelcome. Lol. Thanks for the downvote all below. Thanks for proving my point about the change of behavior.
- shaki-dora 8y agoFacebook doesn’t even have a downvote option.
- Sohcahtoa82 8y agoIt does on some pages' comments. It's a feature they're slowly rolling out.
- dingaling 8y agoOne amelioration would have beem a simple "MCAS ACTIVE" announcement every time it activated. That would have eliminated a lot of checklisting and guesswork in moments of high stress. "What the hell is happening?" "MCAS ACTIVE" "Flip the cutouts!" Why that wasn't mandated by the FAA I have no idea. Instead the pilots are expected to systematically analyse the options whilst trying to stay airborne.
- linuxftw 8y agoHow do we know the software works in all conditions, as described? We don't know it had anything to do with pilot training until the investigation is actually finished. To say it's pilot training is pushing Boeing's narrative.