6 ms·
Zero Hedge is the only site I've ever run into that gets zero checks on NewsGuard [1]. For comparison, InfoWars gets 4 out of 9 [2], and Breitbart gets 5 of 9
by tzs 8y ago
Zero Hedge is the only site I've ever run into that gets zero checks on NewsGuard [1].
For comparison, InfoWars gets 4 out of 9 [2], and Breitbart gets 5 of 9 [3].
National Review, Wall Street Journal, and The Daily Signal all get full check marks [4][5][6], for examples of conservative sites with top ratings.
[1] https://api.newsguardtech.com/1B10A8FE3FE38166041EF99B6BDE6C3DBB841FCEEEDFD4175C9CAF9BCEAB07ABCF99012502C3C4DC775C724D81F8BD39F653709C2AAD5B56?cid=44cf118c-b843-457c-9ee3-c373012ce0ab https://api.newsguardtech.com/1B10A8FE3FE38166041EF99B6BDE6C...
[2] https://api.newsguardtech.com/86BCB950AC90212617C8328B3BDC7B68B20BDD33FCD248691B93109E197C9F9E44BB50D873BA900AB8C95E905C656BA7E5440692C50C963E?cid=44cf118c-b843-457c-9ee3-c373012ce0ab https://api.newsguardtech.com/86BCB950AC90212617C8328B3BDC7B...
[3] https://api.newsguardtech.com/A7F7BCBA597324801963CA38B46F4E412279EF2B902F6DC69519BDCAAD2B71BAF9F8D5C50F7BB8F76C53E4F28607DA131F85A3448CB7BA9D?cid=44cf118c-b843-457c-9ee3-c373012ce0ab https://api.newsguardtech.com/A7F7BCBA597324801963CA38B46F4E...
[4] https://api.newsguardtech.com/5D044567246813D305EF4CFAC2D797885F0AD82B58B017BEAC4882842FEF7AF951596F1DE857E4E8478486785BD6092F5E928D82048DE090?cid=44cf118c-b843-457c-9ee3-c373012ce0ab https://api.newsguardtech.com/5D044567246813D305EF4CFAC2D797...
[5] https://api.newsguardtech.com/BBB6E27D9A686CF806D035DCEC50B4E8B75DA217FFC99423D0825D54D859A811DE4BB78A2523A95B1C3CD32E927C399CD597E709A757BD15?cid=44cf118c-b843-457c-9ee3-c373012ce0ab https://api.newsguardtech.com/BBB6E27D9A686CF806D035DCEC50B4...
[6] https://api.newsguardtech.com/DCFD64CB17AE2BBCC342F9FFD70DB8938BAEE877072465D534DD5A9F1987AEDDE283C08E9B627EDC73D5AE161851EDFC7563BE2C45FA04C4?cid=44cf118c-b843-457c-9ee3-c373012ce0ab https://api.newsguardtech.com/DCFD64CB17AE2BBCC342F9FFD70DB8...
- dev_dull 8y agoHave we as a community decided that newsguard is anything but trash? Why would any of us be willing to submit ourselves to “censorship as a service”? If anything, we need to be breaking apart these types of technological control software. I don’t want anything to do with “newsguard” and I urge others to take a critical eye on that idea as well.
- tptacek 8y agoIndeed, why trust any experts on anything? We should do the legwork, all of it, for every decision we make. Vaccines? I want to see it kill a polio and then not make an autism. The earth? Sure looks flat to me. Can you prove it's round? Then show me how to do it, so I can prove it to myself? Taking other people's word for it is just censoring alternative points of view. This is America. I don't want anything to do with censorship.
- dev_dull 8y agoNewsguard is a technology meant to control what people see, read, and ultimately think. If you don’t immediately see the dangers of that type of technology then I’m not sure what will convince you otherwise.
- tptacek 8y agoThat is exactly what antivax people say about vaccination campaigns. I'm not saying you should trust NewsGuard. I don't know much about them! But the categorical alarm you take to the entire concept of independent news vetting is problematic.
- paper-plate 8y agoYou are a spook, tptacek.
- tivert 8y ago> Newsguard is a technology meant to control what people see, read, and ultimately think. If you don’t immediately see the dangers of that type of technology then I’m not sure what will convince you otherwise. The problems aren't all one one side. There are problems with having technology like Newsguard, and there are problem with not having technology like it. Just today, I came across the phenomenon of partisan propaganda masquerading as local journalism (https://www.snopes.com/news/2019/03/04/activists-setup-local-news-sites/ https://www.snopes.com/news/2019/03/04/activists-setup-local...). I've never used Newsguard, but I really hope it flags stuff like "The Tennessee Star." It'd be a clue to question the source more, and God knows we need more clues to get through our hurried, overloaded lives.
- sleepysysadmin 8y ago>Have we as a community decided that newsguard isn’t anything but trash? Why would any of us be willing to submit ourselves to “censorship as a service”? Worth to look at their sources. But go look at their sources. Virtually all the links dont cover any zerohedge content. I'm of the opinion newsguard is trash.
- nostromo 8y agoZeroHedge isn't supposed to be the Wall Street Journal. It's a blog with lots of hottakes. It's more like BoingBoing or Jezebel than it is the Wall Street Journal.
- sleepysysadmin 8y agoSo I'm looking at the site. Lots of links to go through. Lets just start at link 1 of credibility. Follow the story... it says they took the guns based on the guy open-carrying a gun. Which they explain the red-flag-law and such. Like it makes sense. The cops always overreact at these douchebag open-carry people. Youtube has loads of these videos where people open carry looking to sue the cops under 1984 lawsuits if the cops take their guns. This is a credible story. Then I keep going down the list and they have nothing to do with zerohedge. Sorry but you cant provide a boatload of non-zerohedge articles and assert zerohedge is illegitimate and should be banned off the internet because of not-zero hedge articles.
- tzs 8y agoZH said the seizure was without a warrant. There was a warrant. ZH's source updated their story to reflect this, but ZH did not. > Then I keep going down the list and they have nothing to do with zerohedge The links in the source section include links to ZH stories, links to the sources ZH used, links to fact checking sites, and so on. They are references for the assertions in the text above in the corresponding section.
- gruez 8y ago>In order to view this NewsGuard Nutrition Label, you must have the NewsGuard browser extension installed. yikes. that's going to be a pass for me. edit: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/newsguard/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/newsguard/ >This add-on can: > Access your data for all websites
- tzs 8y agoI didn't realize that you needed the extension to view them. I had thought that all the extension did was lookup links on the current page and add a badge to them summarizing their overall NewsGuard score, and add a mouseover popup for the badges to see the full score, and provide a link to the full report. Edit: actually, the links aren't working for me now, either, and I DO have the extension installed. Edit: it looks like they are time limited links. I just went to Zero Hedge again, got a NewsGuard link, and the long hex string is different. That new link works for me regardless of whether or not I am on a browser with NewsGuard, presumably until it too times out. I don't see any way to make a permanent link to their report for a site.