5 ms·
"[Amazon] has captured 43 percent of all internet retail sales in the United States, with half of all online shopping searches starting on Amazon. In 2016, it h
by mtmail 8y ago
"[Amazon] has captured 43 percent of all internet retail sales in the United States, with half of all online shopping searches starting on Amazon. In 2016, it had over $63 billion in revenue from online sales in the United States — or more than the next 10 top online retailers combined. It controls 74 percent of e-book sales, is the largest seller of clothes online and is set to soon become the biggest apparel retailer in the country." https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/21/opinion/amazon-whole-foods-jeff-bezos.html https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/21/opinion/amazon-whole-food...
- sib 8y agoExactly, so, not a monopoly in ecommerce. And only a single-digit share of commerce. And, of course, there is literally nothing inherently illegal (in the US, at least) about building a monopoly in any case.
- oflannabhra 8y agoI'm not so sure we should be heralding the fact that a single company has not captured all of commerce as a win for competition.
- scarface74 8y agoAnd it “captured it” because of the incompetence of the previous incumbents in retail - Barnes and Noble, Toys R Us, Tower Records, Walmart, etc. Why should the government punish companies because they were able to disrupt incumbents? Should we also punish Apple because RIM and Palm couldn’t compete?
- cgriswald 8y agoYou seem to be arguing for a winner-take-all approach to the market. Should future competitors to [monopolistic entity] be punished because [previous competitors] were unable to effectively compete? In any case, I don't think punishment is really an apt metaphor for breaking apart a monopoly.
- scarface74 8y agoSo back in 1999 people thought that Microsoft would be dominant forever - how did that work out? Every company I named was once dominant. Even Spotify came out of nowhere and made the once dominance iTunes Music Store basically irrelevant without government intervention. It wasn’t government intervention that caused the once The Beleaguered Computer Company that was about to be crushed by MS what it is today.
- cgriswald 8y ago> So back in 1999 people thought that Microsoft would be dominant forever - how did that work out? > It wasn’t government intervention that caused the once The Beleaguered Computer Company that was about to be crushed by MS what it is today. The criticisms of Microsoft weren't that it was preventing Apple from selling computers; but that it was using it's monopoly in the operating system to prevent competition against its other software. > Even Spotify came out of nowhere and made the once dominance iTunes Music Store basically irrelevant without government intervention. And if Apple decided Spotify could not be on the App Store, how would Spotify do then? (Nevermind we're ignoring the "Apple tax".)
- scarface74 8y agoSpotify doesn’t pay an “Apple Tax”. You can’t subscribe to Spotify within the App store.
- cgriswald 8y ago> Spotify doesn’t pay an “Apple Tax”. You can’t subscribe to Spotify within the App store. Spotfy is an example. Plenty of Apps do pay the "Apple tax." I'd get into the complexity of how the "Apple tax" affects Spotify even though it doesn't pay it, but you seem to have already made up your mind about all this regardless of the facts.
- scarface74 8y ago
- eeeeeeeeeeeee 8y agoIt wasn’t only that. Amazon also avoided sales tax for the longest time, while all those brick and mortar stores had to pass that fee to the customer, immediately making it appear less price competitive on top of the added cost of running a physical store.
- scarface74 8y agoThe brick and mortar stores could have easily started another company that was only online. But as far as being uncompetitive because of a previous business model is the entire premise of the “Innovator’s Dilemma”. It’s not the governments responsibility to protect old business models.
- jopsen 8y agoMonopoly or not isn't necessarily the question... In the EU the issue often seems to be abuse of market position. If Facebook were to lock Apple users out of new critically important Instagram filters because they wanted to sell the FacePhone. One could argue that they shouldn't be allowed to abuse their market position in social media to make unfair inroads in the phone market. IMO, these things are hard to regulate, and most of our walled gardens are surprisingly interoperable :)
- baddox 8y ago> there is literally nothing inherently illegal (in the US, at least) about building a monopoly in any case. This is not true, despite being repeated extremely often. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Alcoa https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Alcoa
- jforman 8y agoHuh, that ruling was pretty broad. Only pertains to the 2nd circuit as it wasn't reviewed by SCOTUS, but still. Do you know if it was a key cite in cases in other circuits?
- baddox 8y agoI don't have a good citation, but my impression is that the Alcoa case was quite influential, and significantly expanded the power of antitrust law in practice.
- Matticus_Rex 8y ago"biggest" =/= "monopoly"
- everdev 8y ago43% is a massive market share but a monopoly by the definition of the word has near 100% control of a market. I think the modern test is is it possible for someone to compete with Amazon? Costco and Wallmart certainly do. If you break up Amazon, I think online retail will just move to the next biggest player.
- gamblor956 8y agoThat is not, not has it ever been, the legal definition of monopoly.
- throwawaymath 8y agoWhat is the legal definition of a monopoly? As a followup, should that definition remain the legal definition of a monopoly? Do we need a modern appraisal of that definition?
- y4mi 8y agoA monopoly is when there is no competition. There can be seller and buyer monopolies. While having a huge market share is a given in such a situation, it's nonetheless not the definition
- reallydude 8y agoCompetition is just a weasel word. Existence of multiple parties with overlapping interests is not competition. ie A participant in the market is ignored by the dominant player, who continues to dominate (regardless of any comparable metric), it's a functional monopoly. This is why companies often describe their product as "trust" more so than any specific feature set.
- tathougies 8y agoA buyer 'monopoly' is called a monopsony, not a monopoly.
- everdev 8y ago
- colmvp 8y agoInternet shopping is still very much a small share (~15%) of all shopping that occurs in the United States.