3 ms·
"What is more striking is that, in retrospect, the core piece of the government’s case doesn’t make any sense: of course a browser should be bundled with an ope
by mcguire 8y ago
"What is more striking is that, in retrospect, the core piece of the government’s case doesn’t make any sense: of course a browser should be bundled with an operating system; a new computer without a browser would be practically useless (for one, how do you install a browser?). Moreover, Apple, not without merit, argues that restricting rendering engines to the one that ships with the OS (all browsers on iOS have no choice but to use the built-in rendering engine) has significant security benefits; this is debatable, but ultimately, most don’t care, simply because browsers are means to information, not ends."
Someone may want to revisit this argument.
1. The same way Netscape achieved its original dominance?
2. Integrating a browser engine with the core operating system increases security...how?
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- jlv2 8y ago"a new computer without a browser would be practically useless (for one, how do you install a browser?)" When I read this, I realized that no computers can have browsers!
- cromwellian 8y ago> Integrating a browser engine with the core operating system increases security...how? In particular, how process isolation and Just-In-Time compilers work. Since mobile phones are extremely resource constrained, there's a tradeoff between security and performance that is more difficult on mobile than on the desktop. That means the way things were sandboxed on mobile was different on the desktop. For example, the ability to allocate memory that is both writable and executable, one of the features used by Javascript JITs, opens up a huge attack surface area. Apple basically solved this problem by making JavaScriptCore the only blessed Javascript engine able to do this, and for a long time, only Mobile Safari itself could leverage the JIT. Granted, modern phones can relax this, but there's definitely benefits to controlling the entire stack. For example, some functions of the browser could leverage enclaves or enclave-like containers for privacy oriented calculations.
- akkartik 8y agoThis caught my eye as well. "...a new computer without a browser would be practically useless (for one, how do you install a browser?)." He's confusing network access with a browser, which seems an atrocious mistake. You don't need a browser to support http:// http:// links in the OS.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]