3 ms·
To me, the biggest contradiction (as it seems on the design of the system) is that it seems to rely on very fickle measurements to command big movements on the
by raverbashing 8y ago
To me, the biggest contradiction (as it seems on the design of the system) is that it seems to rely on very fickle measurements to command big movements on the aircraft. So, in the case of Lion Air, you have 2 contradictory inputs and you're basing an automated decision on it?
Also, it seems aviation hasn't caught up with 20th century fluid measuring techniques. Speed of fluids in pipes can be measured non-invasively. With the biggest caveat that doing things inside a pipe on the ground is easier it seems we're still using 19th century techniques to measure fluid speeds and direction. Which didn't matter too much when their noisy/unreliable inputs were simply ignored or compensated by pilots and mechanical devices.
No real world scenario (at least not a surviveable one) can produce the sensor readings that happened in AF447 (sudden drop in airspeed) and in the Lion Air case. But this is being taken at "face value" (there is some filtering) and acted upon it (with no contradictory input from other systems - for example an accelerometers - and yes it's not so obvious how to put everything together).
- dreamcompiler 8y agoThe AoA sensor doesn't measure fluid pressure in a pipe; it measures fluid direction with a small mechanical wing that rotates to align itself with airflow [0]. Thus it has to move, unlike a pitot tube. If it can't rotate for some reason, it gives faulty data. [0] https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/2317/how-does-an-alpha-aoa-vane-work https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/2317/how-does-a...
- raverbashing 8y agoYes, I'm aware of the differences, but you could measure air speed in two axis then calculate AoA from there, that's what I mean.
- burfog 8y agoIt's done. Here you go, only a few hundred dollars: https://www.dynonavionics.com/aoa-pitot-probes.php https://www.dynonavionics.com/aoa-pitot-probes.php
- dreamcompiler 8y agoNice! Finds AoA through vector addition. Now I'm curious why Boeing uses a moving sensor. Seems like having two different kinds would be ideal.