3 ms·
This attitude ignores an awful lot of progress. Or you are just defining regulation to only include the things that favor your argument. For instance, the 40 h
by maxerickson 8y ago
This attitude ignores an awful lot of progress. Or you are just defining regulation to only include the things that favor your argument.
For instance, the 40 hour workweek is a regulation in the US. Are hourly employees the rent seekers there? Or the unions and activists that prompted the change?
- nrb 8y agoYou’re both right, in that regulation serves the group that most successfully steers it. The notion that more often than not, incumbent corporations are the ones writing the regulations, is not exactly controversial. Given the recent treatment of net neutrality, I don’t hold out much faith in the open web getting a fair shake right now.
- ddingus 8y agoInsightful. One could extrapolate this Internet struggle being closely related to how meaningful ordinary people are represented in government. In many democracies, and in the US today, big money owns government to the point of anything at all aimed at defending the interests of ordinary people seems radical? And expensive? We may find there is a cost per person, few dollars per, or small percentage of time needed to participate in the system or be stripped down, devalued, tracked and every other thing possible to make money.
- CryptoPunk 8y agoMandatory minimum employment standards aren't progress. Work hours were declining on their own, just as the trend toward a 4 day work week is happening on its own due to fundamental changes in the economic structure. But point granted that not all regulations are a result of rent-seeking. Some are a consequence of misguided common wisdom (e.g. labor regulations, tariffs, restrictions on foreign investment).
- TeMPOraL 8y agoYeah, right. But you're forgetting few other categories of regulation. Like, protection of health and life - that's something companies don't tend to do on their own; in fact, it usually goes strongly against their interest[0]. Or, protection of environment. Or, protecting people from countless of individually and socially destructive activities that the market will happily engage in if left to its own devices, as evidenced by hundreds of years of history over which those issues were recognized and then regulated. -- [0] - A common theme in recent discussions serves as a great proof: Chinese counterfeits on Amazon. By far, Chinese export goods are a product of an environment free from regulations applying in the Western world - so how come people are so afraid they'll get a Chinese-made toy or baby formula?
- CryptoPunk 8y ago>>Like, protection of health and life - that's something companies don't tend to do on their own The trends in place before labor regulations were enacted were toward workplaces becoming safer over time. Companies absolutely do care about having safe work environments. Where workplaces are less than 100% safe is where trade-offs exist between safety and minimizing spending-outlays that favor minimizing spending outlays, and the simplistic assumption that safety always trumps minimizing spending outlays for the public interest is simply not true, because we live in a complex world where scarcity is a reality, and minimizing costs in one area can increase spending in another, more critical area. >>so how come people are so afraid they'll get a Chinese-made toy or baby formula? Because Amazon has introduced a new market of suppliers and consumers haven't adjusted to it with effective filtering tools, so they're reacting correctly and fearing the unknown until the assessment tooling is in place.