4 ms·
>> Last week, Nature, one of the top scientific journals in the world, ran a review written by Lise Eliot of Gina Rippon’s new book, The Gendered Brain: The New
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
>> Last week, Nature, one of the top scientific journals in the world, ran a review written by Lise Eliot of Gina Rippon’s new book, The Gendered Brain: The New Neuroscience that Shatters the Myth of the Female Brain
For the record, I posted that article on HN 9 days ago. It was almost immediately flagged (going by the fact it collected 18 points). This one seems to have lasted at least twice as long - and I don't understand why. In terms of a controversy, an article in Nature is the definition of an uncontroversial, respected source, whereas Quillette is rather the exact opposite. If a serious debate can be had, it should be over an article on Nature, not an article on Quillette.
I don't want to put this in words like "why was my article downvoted", which would sound too much as if I'm nursing some kind of petty grudge, but the same thing has happened to other articles I've posted previously on matters of gender equality in the sciences, while, for example, articles about James Damore are left alone. Is James Damore less controversial than Gina Rippon?
I must say that I do get a strong feeling that one side of this issue is treated very differently than the other by a significant proportion of users on HN.
- erentz 8y agoA lot of articles on gender get the same flagging treatment. (FWIW Damore is far from uncontroversial here on HN.) I suspect sometimes the flagging treatment is because these articles can attract heated (often emotional) debate, and this might be why some flaggers flag them, to avoid that and just stick to tech stuff. That said I’m always interested in seeing these articles and debates myself, mostly because it’s a pretty important issue in tech and we won’t resolve it if we don’t talk about it. But it’s hard to do. This post may have survived this long just by luck, I wouldn’t read to much into it. But you can certainly talk about it here now since this article is in response to your article. (One question I might’ve asked about your original would be, if male and female brains are really the same then how come rates of certain mental illnesses vary so much between the sexes?) Edit: I realized I originally wrote “far from contoversial” it should be “uncontoversial” but I think that was understandabld from the context.
- drilldrive 8y ago>FWIW Damore is far from controversial here on HN. Just to be clear, in what way? Anti-Google pro-Damore I presume?
- erentz 8y agoFrom what I’ve seen (so it’s anecdotal) they seemed to attract emotional debate, and lots of downvotes, and flags, and people making throwaways before commenting, etc. In that way controversial. To my mind when you see lots of downvoted comments it’s a pretty good sign of a controversial topic because I never usually see that on purely tech topics ok HN. From which I infer on tech topics a bad comment doesn’t get upvoted and sinks because good comments rise. On non tech topics like gender comments (bad or good) can quickly be grayed out by downvotes. I suppose it might be an interesting hypothesis to test somehow if historical HN posts could be classified into topic and we had the voting and flagging data.
- aboutruby 8y agoWhile this subject could be interesting, it always degenerate into culture wars (one side vs the other) which could be considered flamebait: > Eschew flamebait. Don't introduce flamewar topics unless you have something genuinely new to say. Avoid unrelated controversies and generic tangents. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html One solution for this could be to talk about the subject at a more abstract level than an example.
- leereeves 8y agoDoes Hacker News have enough users who are knowledgeable about neuroscience to sustain an evidence based discussion of this topic?
- tomlock 8y agoGreat point. For all their talk about attempting to shatter echo chambers, people with this agenda seem to love upvoting stories that agree with them and downvoting ones that don't. Science is absolutely on the side of journals like Nature, and pays barely any notice to valueless rags like Quillette.
- perilunar 8y ago> Science is absolutely on the side of journals like Nature Argument from Authority? Anyway, this is not Quillette versus Nature: the article points out the reviewed book comes to conclusions (no sex-differences in brains) that disagree with work already published — in Nature (sex differences in grey matter volume, effects of testosterone on in utero brain growth). > valueless rags like Quillette. It's clearly not valueless to subscribers who fund it.
- tomlock 8y agoIf quillette isnt valueless because people subscribe to it, anti-vax rags also have some value. Science is an authority. It authoritatively endorses the view that climate change is happening, and that gender isn't as simple as just the binary. If you view that as fallacious, you're anti-science.
- leereeves 8y agoInvocations of "science" in a political debate are almost always arguments from authority. Few participants or listeners will ever examine the evidence for themselves. And by subtly (and often not-so-subtly) blocking the careers of scientists who express a different view, politicians try to ensure that authority supports their agenda. It's a mechanism of social control that's been used by authoritarian regimes for a hundred years. And if you think that view makes me "anti-science", you should know that I'm currently a graduate student studying science. I'm very much in favor of fair and painstaking examination of empirical evidence. I'm against "science" as a political cudgel. I'm against supporting or rejecting theories based on ideology rather than evidence. I'm against politicians and political activists meddling in science or using selective quoting of unsettled science for political ends.
- aaron695 8y agoBecause it was clickbait junk, no true scientist makes statements like "Beyond the “missing five ounces” of female brain — gloated about since the nineteenth century — modern neuroscientists have identified no decisive, category-defining differences between the brains of men and women." Gloated? Who's gloated? Is this proven in a study? I've never even heard of the missing five ounces let alone heard people gloating about it. This is purely emotional, the endemic 'gloating' probably made up (It doesn't pass the smell test) and has no place in educated discourse. James Damore stated facts, they might have been one sided, however they didn't stoop to this level.
- stared 8y agoQuite a few of my submissions related to sexuality got flagged (e.g. the Dating for Nerds, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15372552 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15372552). While I didn't like it, I understand the motivation - it attracts the wrong kind of discussion (flame wars, us vs them holy crusade, etc; certainly to kind or illuminating).