3 ms·
I disagree, there have been times a well-placed popup stopped me from accidentally doing something really stupid, other times there wasn't a popup and I ended u
by alexanderdmitri 8y ago
I disagree, there have been times a well-placed popup stopped me from accidentally doing something really stupid, other times there wasn't a popup and I ended up doing something stupid.
It doesn't necessarily have to be a pop up popup per say, but extra validation around dangerous actions is user friendly.
And of course there can always be an override for the extra validation in case it potentially screws up some people's workflows, but I'd make a user explicitly set the override, like the 'NoHostAuthenticationForLocalhost' option in ssh for example.
- gowld 8y agoPopups only work if they Confirm button is not a button, but "enter this text exactly: I really want to publish this package to the whole wide world" and block copy-paste. If the user hacks around that, it's their own fault.
- lugg 8y agoIf a pop up is required to prevent you doing something stupid the UX has already failed. I don't think a popup solving a problem means it is solving the right problem in the right way.