3 ms·
> Some things we can measure objectively, and civilizations are rated on a scale. No, they aren't. But even if they were, the best objective measure might be:
by philwelch 8y ago
> Some things we can measure objectively, and civilizations are rated on a scale.
No, they aren't.
But even if they were, the best objective measure might be: given the choice of living within either of two different civilizations, which would people prefer? And from that standpoint, the New World was actually more advanced than Europe:
> I asked seven anthropologists, archaeologists, and historians if they would rather have been a typical Indian or a typical European in 1491. None was delighted by the question, because it required judging the past by the standards of today—a fallacy disparaged as “presentism” by social scientists. But every one chose to be an Indian. Some early colonists gave the same answer. Horrifying the leaders of Jamestown and Plymouth, scores of English ran off to live with the Indians.
Also:
> Back home in the Americas, Indian agriculture long sustained some of the world’s largest cities. The Aztec capital of Tenochtitlán dazzled Hernán Cortés in 1519; it was bigger than Paris, Europe’s greatest metropolis. The Spaniards gawped like hayseeds at the wide streets, ornately carved buildings, and markets bright with goods from hundreds of miles away. They had never before seen a city with botanical gardens, for the excellent reason that none existed in Europe. The same novelty attended the force of a thousand men that kept the crowded streets immaculate. (Streets that weren’t ankle-deep in sewage! The conquistadors had never heard of such a thing.)
> Spaniards, who seldom if ever bathed, were amazed by the Aztec desire for personal cleanliness.
https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2002/03/1491/302445/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2002/03/1491/30...
- oblio 8y ago1. Why do you folks keep moving the goalposts? You're the second person that replies to me almost the same way, primarily not reading my comments. I didn't say the New World vs Europe, I said the New World vs the Old World. There were Asian cities of 1 million people at the time, there's plenty of Asian civilizations where people bathed, etc. Plus saying that the Spaniards hadn't seen such a thing is not saying that much in a time where the average person would travel, on average, at most 20km from their hometown, throughout their entire lives. Even for the average conquistador, this was the trip of their lives. They'd better be impressed by what they see, now that they get to see thing thousands of km away from their home village! :) 2. > No, they aren't. Yes they are, I don't adhere to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cultural_relativism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cultural_relativism. A civilization that has discovered antibiotics is better, all other things being equal, than one that hasn't.
- philwelch 8y agoThe point is that not all other things are equal in the slightest. Referring to American Indian cultures as “backwards” is an arbitrary value judgment and a statement of opinion, not fact.
- jcranmer 8y ago> A civilization that has discovered antibiotics is better, all other things being equal, than one that hasn't. What metric do you mean to use? If you want to measure by health outcomes, the most technologically advanced societies did not surpass paleolithic societies until about the 1950s. For 10,000 years, the healthiest people on the planet would have been "backwards" hunter-gatherer, non-agricultural societies. Even if you want to limit to comparisons between agricultural societies, the Aztecs were probably healthier than the Spaniards they encountered. Technological advancement does not necessarily mean superiority. Another fun fact to point out is that early iron weapons were actually inferior to contemporary bronze weapons. (And the Spaniards' reaction to the Aztec macuahuitl was "ha ha, funny looking weapons… holy crap, those things are deadly dangerous"). If you try to actually start defining objective criteria, the assumption that Western society is/was superior is actually very shaky.
- philwelch 8y agoHorseback archers in open grasslands also retained a massive advantage over firearms until the Colt revolver.