4 ms·
We recently discussed this in another thread, but one of the low observability (stealth) characteristics of the F-117 was a reduced radar cross section (visibil
by runjake 16y ago
We recently discussed this in another thread, but one of the low observability (stealth) characteristics of the F-117 was a reduced radar cross section (visibility) using flat sections of fuselage in a faceted manner.
This was calculated by hand by Skunk Works engineers. They didn't have the benefit of computerized physical modeling back then. They were able to reduce the radar visibility to a size about that of a bird (it's actually a little larger, iirc).
My understanding with Zoltan is that he just looked birds flying at 500-600mph. He claims that he invented all this complex, custom gear accompanied by advanced-sounding jargon, but the US military dismissed it as hyperbole (which Zoltan is known for).
The B-2 had the benefit of computer-aided physical modeling which explains it's lack of facets. The B-1 and B-52 also have low observability characteristics to reduce their radar and infrared characteristics (although they aren't known as "stealth" aircraft).
I think that stealth aircraft as we know them are largely obsolete. Hence, the increased focus on UAVs and satellites. I have some ideas about where to go next, but the costs would make the B-2 look like a Girl Scout cookie sale.
Disclaimer: I worked on many of the above-mentioned aircraft.
- stratomorph 16y ago>The B-1 and B-52 also have low observability characteristics I'd challenge the B-52 bit. The airframe had pretty well reached its final form by 1950. Radar was still in its infancy, let alone radar countermeasures. The plane is all radar-inviting angles (like the giant vertical stab), and there wasn't even an attempt to shield the engine exhausts from IR sensors, as IR homing weapons didn't exist at the time. I'd go so far as to say the B-52 is about as high-observable as an airplane gets. Edit: Maybe you mean active countermeasures?
- runjake 16y agoYou are correct about the airframe, but the airframe wasn't what I was referring to. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radar-absorbent_material http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radar-absorbent_material Active countermeasures aren't very stealthy except when you're attacking a specific detection system.
- Retric 16y agoDeclassified info from 1945 :) page 21 shows some jamming equipment for a B-17. Page 24 even has some spoof equipment for when you want to pretend you brought some friends along. http://www.scribd.com/doc/33263034/WWII-Radar-Countermeasures-Equipment http://www.scribd.com/doc/33263034/WWII-Radar-Countermeasure... PS: And it just keeps going and going. It's crazy to think how far the cat and mouse game was even all the way back then.
- tptacek 16y ago+blink+ Tell us more about you?
- wdewind 16y agoSpecifically, how about an AMA?
- runjake 16y agoI had to Google "AMA". Now I get it. You can ask me anything and I'll do my best to answer. I'm still pretty guarded about info, perhaps unnecessarily, because I'm not sure what is and isn't ok to chat about anymore. 15 years ago, photographs like these would be a big no no: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:20061027-6_b2cockpit-1-515h.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:20061027-6_b2cockpit-1-515... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:B-52_lower_deck.jpg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:B-52_lower_deck.jpg This was apparently publicized at some point, as well: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AGM-129_ACM http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AGM-129_ACM (which I view as the precursor to modern UAVs)
- Dove 16y agoThis was calculated by hand by Skunk Works engineers. They didn't have the benefit of computerized physical modeling back then. Half true. Stealth had been known to be theoretically possible [edit] for a long time. I want to say the critical ideas date to papers in the 1930's, but I'm not sure on that. I do know there were flying attempts at it in the 40's. [/edit] But nobody could really pull it off due to the sheer computation required. Stealth happened when computers got good enough. The critical breakthrough was a computer program. Not a full blown physical model, mind you; a very specific program to solve a very specific mathematical problem created by a very clever mathematician. But a computer program nonetheless. ----------- http://www.456fis.org/F-117_STORY.htm http://www.456fis.org/F-117_STORY.htm In early 1975, the initial Skunk Works Project Team consisted of Ed Martin (Project Manager), Dick Schemer and Denys Overholser. Overholser had recalled a discussion with his then boss, Bill Schroeder, some years earlier, concerning the mathematics and physics of optical scattering. The two had concluded that detectable signatures could be minimized utilizing a shape composed of the smallest number of properly orientated flat panels. In addition, Schroeder believed that it was possible to develop and resolve a mathematical equation capable of calculating analytically, the reflection from a triangular flat panel; this in turn he hypothesized could be applied in a calculation relating to RCS. Overholser had hired his former boss out of retirement and as Schroeder's mathematical computations became available, Overholser and his team of two engineers were able to use these to write the computer program that could evaluate the RCS of prospective design submissions nominated by Dick Scherrer and his group of preliminary design engineers. Derys and his team worked night and day, and in just five weeks produced an RCS prediction program known as 'Echo 1'. The resultant model was a faceted delta wing design which had more than its share of skeptics within the Skunk Works, some in aerodynamics referring to the shape as 'the Hopeless Diamond'. [Edit: Fact check]
- icegreentea 16y agoThe computer's were important not just for calculating the shape of the airframe, but how to fly the damn thing. You could in theory calculate the F-117 (but not the B2's) frame by hand. But flying the F-117 -or any stealth airframe - requires computer guidance. In act, the prototype (Have Blue) just recycled some extra flight computers from the F-16 (which is unstable in one axis... the F-117 is unstable in all three).