3 ms·
It's not fixed until it is fixed. I understand that with physical systems, the cost and complexity of detecting is higher, but if you're putting other people o
by salawat 8y ago
It's not fixed until it is fixed.
I understand that with physical systems, the cost and complexity of detecting is higher, but if you're putting other people on the line, you damn well better do a live test of your vehicle before another living soul not certified as a pilot or flight engineer is allowed on board.
The more I read about this, the more it appears to me that excessive trust is placed on filed paperwork. Nothing says a fix is done like a successful test flight that specifically attempts to recreate the conditions surrounding the original failure.
- Someone1234 8y agoI don't disagree, but now we're holding Lion Air to a much higher standard than any other commercial airline, including US and EU based ones. Certain repairs are tested. Non-safety critical sensors like AOA are not, because you're meant to be able to land if there's a malfunction. Obviously not in this case, which points to procedural problems beyond any one airline.
- salawat 8y agoThe AoA sensor stopped being non-safety critical when it's output was allowed to drive a system capable of endangering the aircraft. I don't believe Lion Air is directly responsible; they didn't test flight it, but they didn't know they should either due to Boeing's poor communication of the functionality and justification for MCAS. It's a grievous failure all around, and yet another reason I stand by the belief that if there is doubt, there is no doubt.