5 ms·
I love the spin you put on it. Palestinian programmers make no less than Israeli programmers in the Israeli high technology sector. In fact, that goes for all j
by dotancohen 8y ago
I love the spin you put on it. Palestinian programmers make no less than Israeli programmers in the Israeli high technology sector. In fact, that goes for all jobs in the Israeli high-tech sector, from PMs to HR, CTOs.
Furthermore, Palestinians in the West bank regularly talk to me about their situation, because I'm what you would call a "settler" and I buy in their towns, and I pick them up hitchhiking, and I talk to them with no borders. They all have family in Jordan and will happily tell you how much better their "occupied" life is than their Jordanian family. And yes, I've been to Jordan and I've been to Egypt and I've been to Lebanon (albeit in uniform on that one).
Dislike Israel's policies as much as you want, I'm unhappy with many of them as well. Hate our PM, you'll find good reason to. But there is no need to lie or put spin on the fact that 99% of Israelis have no qualm with Palestinians or pay them less for equal labour. Likewise, 99% of Palestinians have no qualm with Israel or Israelis, and want (like us) to work hard, come home and love our children, and live in peace with our neighbours.
- fxfan 8y agoThat and the fact that while Israel is blamed for everything, nobody ever mentions how Palestinian children are poisoned with anti-israel rhetoric.
- zymhan 8y agoThis is true for so many conflicts around the world sadly. Hate is everywhere.
- Cyph0n 8y agoAnd Israeli children aren’t? Both sides use outrageous claims to fuel the fire, so to speak.
- fxfan 8y agohow on earth can you compare children toting guns and shouting `death to israel` with whatever the israeli kids are taught? (I doubt they are even told about Palestinians, tbh)
- dotancohen 8y agoIsraeli children are in fact taught about the non-Jewish citizens. I would venture that the vast majority are taught that we're different, but neither of us are "better". We have different holidays, different language, and even measure the year differently, but we can play together and learn each other's language.
- Cyph0n 8y ago> I doubt they are even told about Palestinians, tbh Assuming this were true, how exactly is it a good thing?
- jvzr 8y agoI don't think parent claimed it was a good thing, more like "yeah Israeli children are not taught to shout death chants at Palestinians, in fact I'd venture they are not even taught about Palestinians". Not better, not worse, just a different stroke of bad.
- skinnymuch 8y agoNot being told about the Palestinians at all would be pretty bad. Pretty sure any country with an extremely controversial history dealing with other people not telling children about those people at all is bad.
- dotancohen 8y agoMy children aren't. My children play with Arab children, and share their snacks. I'm 100% certain that my children have influenced at least some Arab children to reject the hatred that they are taught. Note that in the West Bank itself, there are not many opportunities for the children to play together if the parents do not already know each other, because each side is wary of the other. So much of that interaction happens on the other side of the Green Line, with Arab children that do not live in the West Bank.
- stochastic_monk 8y agoCan you blame them? Israel has time and time again committed war crimes, hiding behind accusations of antisemitism whenever anyone calls them out, which cheapens the suffering of people who actually experience antisemitism in order to defend crimes against humanity. From Human Rights Watch [0]: Israel maintains entrenched discriminatory systems that treat Palestinians unequally. Its over half-century-long occupation of the West Bank and Gaza involves systematic rights abuses, including collective punishment, routine use of excessive lethal force, and prolonged administrative detention without charge or trial for hundreds. It builds and supports illegal settlements in the occupied West Bank, expropriating Palestinian land and imposing burdens on Palestinians but not on settlers, restricting their access to basic services and making it nearly impossible for them to build in much of the West Bank without risking demolition. Israel’s decade-long closure of Gaza, supported by Egypt, severely restricts the movement of people and goods, with devastating humanitarian impact. The Palestinian Authority in the West Bank and Hamas in Gaza both sharply restrict dissent, arbitrarily arresting critics and torturing those in their custody. For more details, see [1] and [2]. [0] https://www.hrw.org/middle-east/n-africa/israel/palestine https://www.hrw.org/middle-east/n-africa/israel/palestine [1] https://www.hrw.org/news/2018/06/13/israel-apparent-war-crimes-gaza https://www.hrw.org/news/2018/06/13/israel-apparent-war-crim... [2] https://www.hrw.org/news/2019/01/28/submission-human-rights-watch-committee-economic-social-and-cultural-rights-israel https://www.hrw.org/news/2019/01/28/submission-human-rights-...
- deogeo 8y agoOccupy their land, then accuse them of hate.
- navlelo 8y agoThis is quite interesting. This is not at all how this is portrayed in the media. Would be cool to hear from a palestinian living there as well
- mruts 8y agoI am palestinian and have family in the West bank and Gaza. And what OPs saying isn't true at all. They are an occupied and oppressed people, treated like dirt and without representation. Gaza is literally a concentration camp that is extremely hard to get out of. Moreover, the Israelis block imports of food and building supplies, essentially trying to starve the inhabitants to death. What OP is saying is similar to saying that black people loved slavery and then segregation, because their masters were so fair and kind to them.
- Cyph0n 8y agoRegarding Gaza, what’s truly sad is that Israel allows more aid through its border than Egypt does...
- dotancohen 8y agoI'm the OP, and I agree that the situation in Gaza is beyond reprehensible. I see where Gaza is today, I see how it got there and the Israeli / Egyption hand in it, and I only wonder if it could have worked out differently. I wonder if it can even ever be resolved.
- zymhan 8y agoI mean that directly contradicts the subtitle of this article: > "For the price of one Israeli engineer, an [Israeli] company can hire three Palestinians in the West Bank"
- tootie 8y agoI agree with your sentiment, but the number is way below 99%. You can't blissfully ignore that a substantial number of people on both sides really hate each other. You can't say your PM is a jerk, but not the people because the people voted for him (or at least his party).
- uasm 8y agoSeriously? Would you say the American people are "jerks" because Trump was voted into power? That's not how any of this works.
- majewsky 8y agoThat's a very obvious strawman. If you downsize it to the level that GP alluded to, asking if Trump's voters are jerks because they voted him into power, I guess a non-negligible amount of people would agree.
- uasm 8y agoHave you read tootie's comment at-all? > "You can't say your PM is a jerk, but not the people because the people voted for him (or at least his party)." No, it's not the people. It's some people that voted Likud in. Much like some Americans voted Trump in. Where's the strawman?
- 1024core 8y agoThose "some people" must number more than 1%, right? It is almost impossible to win a non-trivial number of seats in the election if only 1% of the people support you. 30% of Americans even today support Trump. So one would be right to claim that 30% of Americans are jerks.
- conradfr 8y agoThis may be off topic for HN but what do you think the rest of the world think of Americans?
- 8y ago
- mruts 8y agoI'm palestinian and have family in the West bank and Gaza. What you're saying isn't true at all. Funnily enough, I also have family in Jordan. Let me tell you, their lives are much better than those under Israeli occupation.
- dotancohen 8y agoI would appreciate your perspective. I'm sure that many posters here would as well. Another poster here did mention that the fine article mentions that Mellanox can hire three Palestinians for the price of one Israeli. That is not typical of the Israeli high tech sector. It _is_ typical of some other labour markets, notably building and agriculture. Note that I'm specifically referring to the West Bank. I'm sure that the situation in Gaza is so much worse that in my worst dreams I cannot imagine it. From where are your family? I'm in Eshkolot, in the south Hebron hills, right next to Al-Ramadin.
- zymhan 8y agoI'm in the same position. This person is off their rocker.
- dang 8y agoPlease don't call names. That's a sure way to ignite a tinderbox, and a flamewar will do none of us any good. Scorched earth is all the same. Even if completely wrong, the GP is pretty clearly posting in good faith (as you are too, I'm sure). As an alternative, sharing some details of your position would be more interesting and helpful. Only if you want to, of course.
- Cyph0n 8y agoYeah, I’m sure Palestinians living in Jordan have to go through military checkpoints everywhere they go.
- nabla9 8y agoIf you reflect a little, I'm sure that you can backtrack that claim that only 1% of Israelis and Palestinians have qualm with each others. Every country has more bigots than 1%. If you look at Israeli public opinion polls from past ten years or so, you get very different view. 30% feel hatred when they hear Arab spoken in the street, 50% say they would refuse to work at a job where direct supervisor was an Arab.
- dotancohen 8y agoMaybe not 1%, but it really is not a significant portion. At least not in the circles where I am found: 1. I'm "a settler" in the West Bank. 2. I work in Israeli high-tech. 3. I work with mostly religious Jews. Note that the polls suffer from "survivor bias", the people answering the polls are those who feel that they need to should their opinion to the world. I don't answer polls, and with elections coming I get several SMS polls per day sent to my phone. 30% feel hatred when they hear Arabic? Who are they polling?!? There is absolutely no way that is true for the general population. You cannot go anywhere in Israel and not hear Arabic. 50% would refuse to work under Arab supervision? Again, this is ridiculous. I don't think money-sucking Jews would refuse to work under Hitler.
- 1024core 8y ago> Maybe not 1%, but it really is not a significant portion. At least not in the circles where I am found Ah, the "No true Scotsman" defense.
- eganist 8y ago> 50% would refuse to work under Arab supervision? Again, this is ridiculous. I don't think money-sucking Jews would refuse to work under Hitler. Got curious and googled. Couldn't find that last statistic, but it seems 58% (give or take) of residents in the city of Ashkelon were in favor of terminating public works projects (specifically construction of bomb shelters at kindergartens) where Arab workers were employed. Whether this is an effective proxy for all of Israel or even for the question at hand is unknown to me, and it probably isn't the case considering Israeli AG Yehuda Weinstein warned the city's mayor not to execute the decree, but I'm not terribly focused on the decree itself as much as I'm focused on the population backing it. 58% of a city would appear to be fearful of an employed population because of their ethnic heritage... that's terrifying. http://www.timesofisrael.com/ashkelon-mayor-warned-over-arab-worker-ban-but-public-backs-move/ http://www.timesofisrael.com/ashkelon-mayor-warned-over-arab... (p.s. it seems mayor Itamar Shimoni ultimately backed off the move, possibly one of the rare cases where an elected public official made a more well-informed decision than what was desired by the official's constituents. https://www.jta.org/2014/11/23/israel/ashkelon-mayor-decides-against-ban-on-arab-workers-1 https://www.jta.org/2014/11/23/israel/ashkelon-mayor-decides... ) --- Disclosure: I'm an American-born person of Persian descent, though I'm likely unable (and certainly unwilling) to revisit Persia/Iran under the current regime.
- skinnymuch 8y agoWhat you’re saying already seems a bit suspect. Especially with you commenting on someone else putting spin on something you appear to be putting spin on. Then you start things off with going against what the OP’s article says in its subtitle without any backing: “'For the price of one Israeli engineer, an [Israeli] company can hire three Palestinians in the West Bank, and they have very high motivation'” Likewise, the 1% of Palestinians and Israelis have any qualms with one another also has no backing by any data or real life. Since it also isn’t true at all and there’s actually polls, maybe studies, to show that isn’t true. Too much spin.
- 1024core 8y ago> because I'm what you would call a "settler" Not just "you"; everyone. It is illegal. Even the UN has called for an end to this practice. Most countries don't recognize Israel's occupation of the West Bank. The UNSC has condemned the practice. Israel routinely destroys Palestinian homes and villages for the benefit of you people (the "settlers"). https://www.presstv.com/Detail/2019/02/09/588118/Israel-to-confiscate-Palestinian-land-for-sewage-network-in-central-West-Bank https://www.presstv.com/Detail/2019/02/09/588118/Israel-to-c... Read more about "settlers": https://www.btselem.org/topic/settler_violence https://www.btselem.org/topic/settler_violence
- dang 8y agoCan you please make sure to edit out swipes, especially when posting on divisive topics? Your comment would be fine without the first bit.