3 ms·
The problem with this line of thinking is that everything we do in our lives, especially rational thought and communication based on it, pre-supposes some sense
by tsimionescu 8y ago
The problem with this line of thinking is that everything we do in our lives, especially rational thought and communication based on it, pre-supposes some sense of free will.
In particular, it is well known that if you don't believe in any degree of free will, the stranger quantum effects (or basically any kind of statistical thinking) can be ignored - if the experiment to be run is itself pre-determined, then hidden variables that correlate the behavior of the experiment with the 'decisions' of the experimenter can't be ruled out anymore.
Perhaps more fundamentally, if you believe that there is absolutely no free will, then of course this conversation is essentially pointless, eve though we were forced into it by the big bang.
- cortic 8y agoThe presupposition of everything we do in life may be essentially wrong. >if you believe that there is absolutely no free will, then of course this conversation is essentially pointless If you are absolutely devoted to defining yourself as the ghost in the machine in a world where ghosts have been disproved; But if you can redefine 'you' to mean the machine, then your actions are an extension of who you are. So you can't choose to be someone other than yourself, but what value did that add anyway?