3 ms·
> No latitude. No longitude. That's wrong. Tracking which star zeniths is exactly latitude.. you measure, for example Arcturus (which is super easy to find)
by dnautics 8y ago
> No latitude. No longitude.
That's wrong. Tracking which star zeniths is exactly latitude.. you measure, for example Arcturus (which is super easy to find) for Hawaii or Sirius for Tahiti, and keep going due South or North until the "home star" zeniths; you can nearly guarantee due north and southness by traveling perpendicular to solar or stellar motion. Then you head due east or west (which does require stateful knowledge); accuracy can be in a say 200 mile swath and by carefully observing clouds which rise due to orographic precipitation, you can know when you're close.
- ardy42 8y ago>> Note what is missing. No latitude. No longitude. No time source. > That's wrong. Tracking which star zeniths is exactly latitude.. I think you missed the point. Latitude and longitude are Western concepts; concepts which the Polynesians did not actually use as such. However, they were navigators, so some of their navigational concepts and practices would obviously map to the concepts of other navigators due to a shared domain. Similarly, they obviously had some concept of time. You could probably map their concepts onto hours and minutes, but if someone said they didn't have hours and minutes, they'd be right. The existence of the mapping doesn't invalidate that.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- btilly 8y agoThat's wrong. Tracking which star zeniths is exactly latitude. Read my description again. You will see that the navigational strategy is based on setting out in the right direction and keeping your bearing steady, then being able to tell when you get close enough. In particular you do not track which star is at the zenith. That judgement is too hard to make with the naked eye on a rocking boat with no instruments. And therefore you do not know where you are. Which means that you do not know your latitude/longitude. (Though they did know roughly how long each journey would be.)
- dnautics 8y ago> During the night use the points where specific stars rise and set to be sure you're still going in the right direction. That is equivalent to contextually figuring out which star zeniths, and in particular stars were assigned names to island groups based on which one zeniths, for example hokule'a for Hawaii.