6 ms·
> Do you understand that the iPhone does not keep personal and company data separate? Yes, of course. I just think it's the employer's problem in this case, no
by Silhouette 16y ago
> Do you understand that the iPhone does not keep personal and company data separate?
Yes, of course. I just think it's the employer's problem in this case, not the employee's.
> Do you agree that the distinction between personal and company is vague and human defined?
No. The argument made by many people disagreeing with me in this discussion is predicated on the employee downloading data from the company Exchange system. That provides an objective standard for what constitutes "company data".
If you're going to try to broaden that in some ill-defined way to any other data the employee has, you might as well argue that any employer should have the right to audit any and all of an employee's personal property, communications or brainwaves. I am aware that some employers actually do seem to think that at least the first two are reasonable, but I vehemently disagree with them, and so does the law in most places.
> What kind of high-end security hardware are you talking about?
The relevant ones here typically record/block/modify network traffic: intrusion detection, data leakage prevention, lawful intercept, that kind of thing.
> If you used an advanced Cisco software VPN client, you could (so I hear) have it scan the client computer and enforce policies on it. If it was used on a personal computer, these would be invasive in a similar way yet you would not blame Cisco or the company if the user didn't understand this, would you?
You mean if
(a) an employee was asked to work from home,
(b) the employee was asked to access the company network using company-provided software installed on their personal computer (the VPN client), and
(c) that software then reformatted the employee's hard drive because someone in corporate IT hit the wrong button by accident,
would I have the same problem with it?
Yes, of course. As I keep saying, if the company requires that kind of control, it should be issuing employees with dedicated systems at company expense, configured appropriately. I struggle to see any circumstances under which installing software on an employee's personal property that gives the employer the ability to wipe the entire machine arbitrarily would ever be justified.
- tptacek 16y agoExactly how does a DLP system help a company whose employees are allowed to use iPhones for company mail, when company mail is streaked through with protected information like bacon is with pig fat? People put network DLP systems on their perimeters, so they can catch data walking out the front door. Protected information is supposed to walk over email; people use it to get their jobs done.
- Silhouette 16y ago> Exactly how does a DLP system help a company whose employees are allowed to use iPhones for company mail, when company mail is streaked through with protected information like bacon is with pig fat? Exactly, it doesn't! If you have data that is important enough for leakage control at the edge of your network, then it must not be accessible outside of your controlled systems at all. An employee's personal phone is never a controlled system for the purposes of this policy. After all, what if the phone isn't stolen, but infected by a data-stealing virus during the employee's personal use?
- tptacek 16y agoThis is called a "risk". Companies do different things in response to different risks. To the "company will lose $100MM if one of 150 different people lose their phone" risk, many companies have adopted the "nuke from orbit" control. To the "phones may be infected by data-stealing viruses" risk, most companies have adopted the "qualified stake holder for affected data has signed a document attesting to the company's acceptance of that risk". If companies had the black-and-white perspective on risk you have here, nobody would ever be able to deploy a line of code.
- Silhouette 16y agoI don't have a black-and-white perspective on risk, but either the data is worth protecting at a remote-wipe kind of level or it's not. In most cases, the ability to wipe a typical employee's personal phone in response to anything would be a ludicrous over-reaction. On the other hand, if you have someone who really does need to access sensitive data on their phone, and leaking that data is a $100,000,000 kind of risk, and there is $100,000s of layered security that normally protects that data, then maybe company IT should be authorised to spend $100s on a properly secured device that they can remote wipe if necessary, in preference to giving an obvious attack vector straight past that security. As you say, it's about the risk. I don't see any circumstances under which risking using an employee's personal phone to access genuinely sensitive data off-network is justified. Either the damage if it leaks is bad, in which case the barrier for providing a company phone is pretty low, or the damage is negligible, in which case requiring a remote wipe facility that can destroy the employee's own property is silly.
- jodrellblank 16y agoYes, of course. I just think it's the employer's problem in this case, not the employee's. I think it's the employees. You know, because it's their phone and in their interest to keep it separate. Did they ask their phone vendor for a phone which could keep the data separate? Did they read the user manual? Did they vote with their feet or dollars? Did they give a damn at all? > Do you agree that the distinction between personal and company is vague and human defined? No. The argument made by many people disagreeing with me in this discussion is predicated on the employee downloading data from the company Exchange system. That provides an objective standard for what constitutes "company data". But if I sync my contacts with a company Exchange server, I cannot add contacts without them being stored on the Exchange server. If I add a personal contact, those details are sent to the company. Is this now personal or company data? How is the Exchange server to know that you don't want contact X deleted? And why should it listen to you if that would just be a way around it's security? If I open an email with a picture and save it, it goes into the camera roll as a copy. Is that now a personal copy or a company file? If I get a company email with a link to the corporate intranet and I login, is the cached data in Safari which has corporate data in it but which did not come from the Exchange server, is that company or personal? If you're going to try to broaden that in some ill-defined way to any other data the employee has, you might as well argue that any employer should have the right to audit any and all of an employee's personal property, communications or brainwaves. No, that would be stupid. As I keep saying, if the company requires that kind of control, it should be issuing employees with dedicated systems at company expense, configured appropriately No it shouldn't. If the company requires work from home it should issue dedicated systems at company expense. If it merely requires control over whatever system you use then it should only provide advice and understanding when you agree to that control. Just because a company requires control should you wish to access things remotely does not mean that they are obliged to provide the device. Only if they require you to use a device should they provide one. If they do not require it but you choose to provide one, they should be allowed to require restrictions and refuse if you do not agree. The interesting bit is that these restrictions are a) not intuitive to a nontechnical person b) obvious to anyone who knows about them. I struggle to see any circumstances under which installing software on an employee's personal property that gives the employer the ability to wipe the entire machine arbitrarily would ever be justified. When that personal property has no other support for erasing important data apart from wiping the entire machine, yet the company mandates that devices be able to erase company data. What else do you want? You keep switching between: - Some perfect device which does not exist - The scenario in the newsitem, where nothing bad happened except the person was shocked and annoyed - Some hypothetical scenario where extreme damage was done to the person What are you really arguing? That it's unfair? That it's less than ideal? That the company is horrible? That Microsoft is horrible? What's your point? iPhones and other activesync devices cannot but wipe everything or nothing, and companies do demand the ability to wipe data. Some companies may demand employees buy personal devices for work use, that's unpleasant and possibly illegal. Many do not. Those that do not often give people the option to use approved personal devices if they prefer them to work provided ones. If people choose to do that without understanding what they are doing, that is unfortunate. In an ideal world it wouldn't happen, but it does actually happen. The best thing to do is: a) Have backups of your important stuff b) Have a mindset where you can accept things goind weirdly in systems you don't understand. c) Have a mindset that you accept the more technical and complex the systems involved in your life are, the more this sort of thing is going to happen.