4 ms·
> Our ability to represent a concept with an abstract sign is something no other animal, not even our closest cousins the chimpanzees, can do. It is arguably al
by Razengan 8y ago
> Our ability to represent a concept with an abstract sign is something no other animal, not even our closest cousins the chimpanzees, can do. It is arguably also the foundation for our advanced, global culture.
Human chauvinisms.
Until we can objectively test the likelihood of humans that have never been taught a language, like "feral children" [0], to spontaneously develop a coding system on their own, can we really compare innate intelligence in these areas across species?
For all we know, the trigger for such developments may be watching others of your own kind doing something odd, that is interesting or beneficial enough to catch on for long enough to be passed on to offspring.
In the Blue Planet 2 series, there is a segment about an octopus and a grouper fish, entirely different species, communicating with each other via gestures and changing their skin colors, to work together in trapping prey.
Ants etc. use "abstract signs" of pheromones. Bees use 3-dimensional dances to communicate. Are we dumber than them because of our inability to do that?
Intelligence certainly isn't a linear 1D scale with discrete steps.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feral_child https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feral_child
- charonn0 8y ago> Until we can objectively test the likelihood of humans that have never been taught a language, like "feral children" [0], to spontaneously develop a coding system on their own, can we really compare innate intelligence in these areas across species? Nicaraguan Sign Language[1] developed spontaneously among a group of deaf children. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicaraguan_Sign_Language https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicaraguan_Sign_Language
- Razengan 8y agoThat's interesting, but those children were already exposed to civilization and in contact with language-using humans. How likely is a human to develop any of our abilities that we take for granted, in the wild?
- 781 8y agoWe tried to teach various animals language and mostly failed. Thus there is indeed a class difference between humans and the rest of animals. The rest of animals seem incapable of this ability, even when we try our best to teach them.
- perfmode 8y agoThat’s our failure. Not theirs. One huge failure is thinking that animals should care to learn anything we teach them.
- whatshisface 8y agoIf animals are unable to direct their attention towards learning to do something, that's functionally identitical to them not being able to do it. Even in an alternate universe where the only reason dogs can't speak English is that they can't work up the focus to sit down with a copy of Strunk and White, it would still be correct to say that animals lack the capacity for language.
- perfmode 8y agoYou're assuming that not doing something implies an inability. Does the fact that I have not adopted your position imply that I am unable to do so? Why can't I be unwilling?
- agumonkey 8y agoI wonder if it's a matter of skill or desire
- hyperpallium 8y agoOr, evolutionary advantage (primarily in the meme sense, but also genetically, for improving physiological and neurological support for language). In what contexts does abstract language confer a survival or reproductive advantage, beyond simple communication, which is a commonplace, e.g. predator warning, food location, mate-seeking.
- hyperpallium 8y agoYou can argue for their intelligence, but they can't argue for yours.
- simonh 8y agoI think you're conflating direct communication with abstract representation. We know that (AFAIK) all primates, and many other animals signal each other, but have failed to find any sign of them creating abstract representations or being capable of learning them despite many concerted efforts to teach them, particularly with primates but other animals too. I think it's clear that these are distinct skills. Regarding your speculation that it has to involve members of the same species, I don't see any evidence based reason to suspect that and plenty not to. It's looks a lot like special pleading. We've had great success teaching animals to do all sorts of complex tasks. You yourself cite an example of sophisticated inter-species communications and co-operation that argues pretty strongly against the expectation for any requirement for intra-special specificity to communications or learning in general. So given that there don't seem to be any other tasks, skills or communications facilities that require same-species specificity, I'd need to see an argument as to why this one skill is special and might not be communicable across species, when we've not come across such a barrier before.
- Razengan 8y ago> any sign of them creating abstract representations Using pheromones to mark "food is here" vs. using an object to deface another object. Or moving your body in space to communicate somewhat-abstract concepts like distance. [0][1] Why would they need to "resort" to writing, yet? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bee_learning_and_communication https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bee_learning_and_communication [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waggle_dance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Waggle_dance