4 ms·
Holmes is under indictment in federal court on charges that would produce a 20 year sentence... I think if you want to play the "what's more interesting" game,
by ajross 8y ago
Holmes is under indictment in federal court on charges that would produce a 20 year sentence...
I think if you want to play the "what's more interesting" game, it isn't that Theranos was particularly notable. Scams happen all the time, and at the end of the day the crime was to have taken $700M in investments based on a lie. I mean, that's, like, really bad. But be real: we're hardly talking Enron or Madoff here.
But some folks just Won't Let Theranos Go. It comes up again and again and again as some kind of existential moral statement instead of the one-every-few-years business scandal that it actually is. And as far as I can tell, the only reason for this is that some of the early investors (that's right, the victims of the crime) were Democrats.
- doctorpangloss 8y agoAh yes, those Democrat Theranos board members and investors, George Schultz and Henry Kissinger! They contributed their significant liberal viewpoints to the well-known Democrat partisan politicians Richard Nixon and Ronald Reagan! In seriousness, I know in some narrow and uninteresting sense you regard your point of view as accurate. But surely the fact that so many supposedly smart people were duped is what made these stories newsworthy.
- ben_jones 8y agoHonestly I think its more because Theranos pierced the Silicon Valley Charade in a way people just couldn't ignore. * You mean every AI/Hardware/Cloud start-up isn't a magic factory of philanthropy/social justice/innovation?? * You mean investors/rich-people make MISTAKES?? But they PAY people to do due-diligence right? * You mean coming from a wealthy, well-connected, family, gives you an egregious head start in the diverse and democratizing tech world?? * You mean a Woman can lie, cheat, and steal, just like a Man?
- randycupertino 8y ago> But some folks just Won't Let Theranos Go. It comes up again and again and again as some kind of existential moral statement instead of the one-every-few-years business scandal that it actually is. And as far as I can tell, the only reason for this is that some of the early investors (that's right, the victims of the crime) were Democrats. What? No... it's because we'd never seen the Silicon Valley Startup Hype Machine ramped up to it's fully glory before like Theranos. Also svelte young blueeyed blondes are catnip to media, combine that with "youngest self made female billionaire" and it's mandatory reporting and guaranteed spotlight in the public eye... throwing the fact that it was all a scam and renewed interest and modern popularity with TrueCrime genre and modern scammers like Anna Delvey and Fyre Festival and .... kaboom, here we are. Didn't hurt that Bad Blood was also excellently written and well-researched. All in all an excellent story.
- bsder 8y ago> it isn't that Theranos was particularly notable Yes, actually, it was. The primary issue is that Silicon Valley runs on "Fake It Until You Make It" very strongly. That's not a real big deal when you are delivering dog food or hooking up hipsters for sex--the money simply goes down the drain and that's life. Once you start the path toward something that has real consequence--diagnosing medical issues or piloting a 2 ton death machine without a human--you've jumped a VERY important line. "Fake It Until You Make It" isn't good enough--engineering now matters and people can get badly hurt. The standard goes up and you had better pay attention. The secondary issue was the nature of Holmes privilege. She had no qualifications to do what she was doing and still managed to pull in a whopping amount of funding from very connected people without oversight--not necessarily an issue in and unto itself. However, when things were going badly, she didn't fess up--she pressed forward by lying about it and then intimidated (possibly criminally) those who attempted to expose it. That's crossing the line. And, to be fair, I find the "scientists" who were Theranos' mouthpieces through this to be far more guilty and wish their names were being promulgated much more strongly so that they can suffer the appropriate censure for aiding and abetting her.