5 ms·
Seems like the housing tax is working as intended. The most interesting part is how this is one of the few serious sources of backpressure on rent. Normally l
by jandrese 8y ago
Seems like the housing tax is working as intended.
The most interesting part is how this is one of the few serious sources of backpressure on rent. Normally landlords are so loathe to reduce rents that they'll let a property sit vacant for months, but this tax makes that extremely painful so they're forced to instead meet the market on rent prices.
- somethoughts 8y agoYes - this seems like it might be an interesting avenue to take for high cost of living cities with a lot of foreign owned condos like New York City.
- branchless 8y agoIt's called land value tax, it's been known for over 100 years. Many on HN think it's "socialism" as their flawed semi-liberal ideology has private property ownership without rent at its core.
- electricslpnsld 8y ago> Normally landlords are so loathe to reduce rents What's the reasoning here? I've tried to talk landlords down by less than a month's rent when taken over the course of a typical year lease, been told to shove off, only to watch the unit go unrented for months until they finally drop the price.
- jaggederest 8y agoThe cap ratio is based on base rent, rather than rent times occupancy. Especially if you have multiple properties, lowering the rent on any of them will negatively affect the rent on the others. This is especially true in commercial real estate, where your other tenants (e.g. in the same mall) sometimes have a "most favored nation" provision - if anyone else gets lower rent, they do too.
- refurb 8y agoLandlord’s are much more likely to kick money back, but keep the rent the same. I’ve even seen it in SF lately - sign a 12 month lease and your first month is free.
- branchless 8y agoIt's a combination of greed and stupidity.
- tinco 8y agoSomething I've heard a landlord argue was that if he lowered his rent that would mean his property value would go down which would mean his loans/mortgages would not be covered. He would rather take a couple months of losses than devalueing his property. I have no idea if the math works out for that, and he was negotiating, but he didn't budge a cent and we took our business elsewhere so it did seem like his hands were tied the same as your example.
- anitil 8y agoI have heard similar arguments from developers in Sydney. They will give you a car, or guaranteed rental income for x months, rather than dropping the price of the property.
- hellisothers 8y agoAs the other reply mentioned, the value of commercial rental property is a multiplier of the rent you can charge. If you lower your rents then not only are you lowering your cash flow but you’re lowering the value of the property overall which can impact resale value and the ability to take out loans.
- ygjb 8y agoI got out of the landlord game a couple years ago because I was tired of the drama, but my biggest source of resistance to lowering rent was the constraints on raising it. Beyond that, I never had a single unit go unrented for more than a single month, and in that case it was because we had some hiccups around upgrades to the unit. That may be unique to the Vancouver market though.
- duado 8y agoWas it in a multi unit building? A guy renting out one condo has an incentive to avoid letting it sit. But a person renting 100 units in a building would rather have it sit than rent it out for $100 less and then having every future (and perhaps existing) tenant expect to pay that new rate.
- slavik81 8y agoConversely, I have never had any problems negotiating rent down by pointing to comparable listings for units at lower prices. It's a hassle to find another good tenant, and there's a decent chance of losing a month's rent to vacancy. The flip side to it is that I'm actually willing to move if they say no. I would rather not, because moving is a pain, but if you're not willing to take the other listing, it wasn't really comparable. edit: However, I have only negotiated with individual landlords in AB. I have not tried in BC.
- onlyrealcuzzo 8y agoAFAIK, at least for large residential complexes, the reason is that you can borrow against the base rent, mostly regardless of the vacancy rate. So if you are renting 60% of your units at $4k per month, you can borrow against the income you'd make if you had all 100% rented out. But if you had to lower the rent on the other 40% by $1k to get 90% occupancy -- you'd have a larger income, but be able to borrow less money. If your goal is to use leverage to borrow as much as you can and cash out before the cycle ends (which I think is what most people are doing in RE) then this is how you do it.
- Tiktaalik 8y agoBC has rent control so to some degree that landlord could be locked into that lower rent regardless of market changes.
- xkcd-sucks 8y agoIf they can report it as "lost income" then there could be tax benefits
- baybal2 8y ago> Seems like the housing tax is working as intended. Yep, the more of a mansion you have, the more you are hit, and the less likely you can get a renter who will be ready to pay the premium rate. Moreover, "antislum" rules in some parts of regional district may prohibit subdividing the property for rent. Ironically, they were said to be passed under the influence from NIMBY people.
- walshemj 8y agoFor good reasons ask nonstudent residents what happens when you get a lot of houses subdivided out in this way.
- 781 8y agoNot really: > While most owners contacted by CTV News said they don’t want groups renting out the homes, the rentals present a cheaper housing alternative for students and young professionals. Huge mansions rented to a single person.
- mandelbrotwurst 8y agoMany have roommates. From the article: "these rentals offer a single room in a multi-bedroom house for anywhere between $700 and $1,500"
- klyrs 8y agoSpeaking as somebody who works in tech and can't afford to live in the city... this is hilarious. If I could afford rent at $6k/mo, I'd just buy myself a 3br fixer-upper for a million bucks. Are these investers going to hold out for unicorn "stupid rich" renters?
- mattnewport 8y ago> But these rentals offer a single room in a multi-bedroom house for anywhere between $700 and $1,500 I read this with your quote as saying they don't want to rent to groups of students who already know each other, presumably because they don't want their luxury mansion turning into a frat house cum party pad and possibly getting trashed. They are renting rooms out to multiple individuals who are sharing the properties however.
- skybrian 8y agoIt's a start. I doubt this is the steady state. I would expect fewer restrictions and higher rents as word gets out, the owners get more comfortable renting, and they find tenants they like.
- refurb 8y agoVancouver has extremely tenant friendly rental laws. I’m not as familiar with them when it comes to sfh, but these tenants may not be easy to evict when the owner wants to move back in or sell.