21 ms·
Enumerating points: 1. Free market economy exists in Asia. Singapore, for example..is run like a corporation. I want to say it’s a free market economy but it’s
by jelliclesfarm 8y ago
Enumerating points:
1. Free market economy exists in Asia. Singapore, for example..is run like a corporation. I want to say it’s a free market economy but it’s only partly free markets. Because of its resource limitations, there is some govt interventions. It is not self sufficient and yet it functions smoothly. So that would be the model closest to what’s in my mind of a free market economy.
2. We are ‘going back’ on a timeline of self sufficiency. A hunter gatherer didn’t have markets. There was no supply chain or cold chain or transportation. They ate when they hunted and foraged the rest of the time leaving a lot of free time. Of course, I am not saying that we ought to go back to being hunter gatherers ..I am just saying that the world has not become smaller physically but the resources have shrunk. It’s the physical dimensions of resources, water, energy etc that must be localized and where we ought to be self sufficient.
My ‘lived experience’ is high density highly populous urban experience.
3. There is no doubt that current Ag practices have to change. Most of it has to go indoors.
4. I also feel that high density living has its advantages as long as the resources needed for the tightly packed people are also accessible.
You mention NYC. It has a good transport network and parks and ingress/egress and homes and offices and shopping. So even though it’s high density, it’s liveable.
I live in a Silicon Valley suburb that is transforming into high density and just high density housing. And it’s awful. Because we have traffic issues and no public transport. The city isn’t walkable and there is no shopping or entertainment and people who work here travel from far off and those who live here work elsewhere. It’s an unformed high density failed city with no ecosystem.
There is a troubling trend (here in California and in urban hearts) where housing is being concentrated with high density goals without providing infrastructure or an eco system. It’s crippling. The local economy suffers..local businesses suffer...infrastructure degrades faster and schools become over crowded. To me..it’s a bad example of high density ..nyc is a workable model of high density.
Mobility and roads will be the key to how successful a city can be..and for that we rely on fossil fuel. But think 100 years down the timeline or a time when fossil fuels becomes less available ..cities may become isolated and they would need to be self sufficient modules that are networked to other city clusters and yet even operating independently, they don’t collapse.
5. I dont worry too much about the cost of technology or labour to create technology. As far as I am concerned, money is something we can print. We will never run out of it. The detail is in the macro and micro economic word wrangling.
Resources ..on the other hand..are finite. Fossil fuel is finite..water, top soil ..the space around us. Regardless of how high density can be packaged as ‘sustainable’, we still need resources to maintain every warm body. A lettuce grown in your hydroponic or soil kitchen garden takes less resources than one that is grown 3000 miles away and is transported and refrigerated and sold in a store and then people are paid to sell it to you and you have to bring it back home. And by this time, the lettuce is likely 10 days from the time it was harvested.
It’s a ridiculous amount of energy spent on lettuce you can grow from seed and pick whenever you want. So why don’t we do this? Why can’t we grow at least half of our food at home? We have a laundry machine and dishwasher and fridge all built in to the house. Why not a hydroponic cupboard that is part of the home construction? Why not a roof top garden or a attached temperature controlled greenhouse like it’s another bedroom or a bathroom. The marginal cost isn’t a lot but energy savings is enormous.
6. Further..think at a larger scale. If a city can grow all it’s herbs and nightshades and greens but only needs to buy grains and nuts and fruits from outside markets, it’s all the more self sufficient. Every city can do what it does best and relies on outside clusters for what it lacks.
7. I have a farm. There is no justification to make a human being work under the merciless sun..bending and picking fruit or lettuce for eight hours a day for minimum wage. We are not doing anyone any favors. Its borderline disgusting to me and highly illogical and unnecessary.
- eesmith 8y agoIf the mixed capitalism and socialism model of Singapore - http://www.rollingalpha.com/2015/03/23/singapore-a-success-story-not-a-free-market-one/ http://www.rollingalpha.com/2015/03/23/singapore-a-success-s... - is a free market then the US now is also a free market. You now write "going back’ on a timeline of self sufficiency .. A hunter gatherer didn’t have markets". However, earlier you wrote "back to the times when we can have free markets AND a limited amount of protectionism AND self sufficiency", so you clearly weren't talking about hunter gatherers then. FWIW, I think your view of hunter gatherers is idealistic rather than being based on (for example) archeological evidence. You write that they had "no supply chain or cold chain or transportation". Quoting http://www.public.asu.edu/~mesmith9/1-CompleteSet/MES-10-TradeEncyc.pdf http://www.public.asu.edu/~mesmith9/1-CompleteSet/MES-10-Tra... "Trade was widely practiced in all parts of the ancient New World, among societies of all levels of social complexity, from the earliest hunter-gatherers to late prehistoric empires like the Aztec and Inca." Quoting http://members.peak.org/~obsidian/pdf/connolly_etal_2015.pdf http://members.peak.org/~obsidian/pdf/connolly_etal_2015.pdf "This contrast suggests that obsidian toolstone procurement in the caldera during middle Holocene and later times was not simply an activity embedded into a complex of hunter-gatherer routines, but a targeted activity on a scale that suggests a commercial enterprise." Quite clearly hunter gatherers had supply chains and transportation. You write "Most of it has to go indoors." I quote the Wikipedia entry for CEA: "The economics of indoor farming has been challenging, particularly the price of electricity, and several startups shut down as a result." As the source reference for that quote points out, at https://finance-commerce.com/2018/05/people-power-costs-keep-indoor-farming-down-to-earth/ https://finance-commerce.com/2018/05/people-power-costs-keep... , "It’s tough to compete with plants grown in dirt with free sunlight, after all." Moreover, if we switch to a solar power economy, then your proposal turns sunlight into electricity (energy loss), into LED lighting (energy loss) into plant growth. That is, current indoor farming uses power which mostly comes from relatively cheap but non-sustainable non-renewables (70% of the power in the US comes from coal, natural gas, or petroleum.) You write "I also feel that high density living has its advantages". This seems to contradict your earlier statement "I am not impressed by the arguments made by high density proponents. In my lived experience, it degrades quality of life." Now you clarify that your experience is that of a post-war American city designed around cars. However, 'the arguments made by high density proponents' are specifically saying that car travel and designs like what you mention must be avoided. (Eg, in http://www.hcd.ca.gov/community-development/community-acceptance/index/docs/mythsnfacts.pdf http://www.hcd.ca.gov/community-development/community-accept... - "With high-density housing, stores serving neighborhood residents move in, allowing residents to walk to buy groceries or to the dry cleaner instead of driving.") So you do agree with them. I mentioned NYC to show that your view of what society should be is not reasonable, in the senses that 1) it requires much more land area, with more duplicated resources (eg, water treatment facilities cannot be shared), 2) it reduces the diversity of experiences that people can have, and 3) the fact that millions of people live in NYC means that your views are far from commonplace. You write "A lettuce grown in your hydroponic or soil kitchen garden takes less resources than one that is grown 3000 miles away and is transported and refrigerated and sold in a store and then people are paid to sell it to you and you have to bring it back home." The failure of many hydroponic farms shows that your statement is not trivially true. You know there are disadvantages to your model, right? It means that everyone currently living in an apartment now needs more space in order to grow those crops. That space is expensive, both because city land is more expensive than rural land, but also because the costs are not shared with anyone else. How much more expensive are the construction costs for everyone to have an extra hydro room? It looks like about $150/sq. ft. for the US and you're talking, what, 100 sq. ft. so $15000? Price of organic lettuce at a farmer's market is about $2, says https://thenaturalfarmer.org/article/price-comparison-of-farmers-markets-grocery-stores-and-co-ops-on-organic-and-conventional-food/ https://thenaturalfarmer.org/article/price-comparison-of-far... , so that's 7,000 heads of lettuce. Now add in the price for the hydroponics equipment and power. In addition, my time isn't free. These aren't turn-key operations you're talking about and it takes time to learn how to farm. Many of the people doing home hydroponics do so as a hobby so value the farming experience. Also, if I go on a trip for a month, what happens to my home farm? Sure, there can be farm sitters, just like there are dog/cat sitters, but that's also not cheap. Finally on this point, I've lived in apartments with shared laundry machines, and houses with no laundry machines - we used laundromats. This suggests that your views on what are reasonable seem based on being rich - you have a farm in Silicon Valley - and living in suburban houses. You write "If a city can grow". And if wishes were horses, beggars would ride. Again, the experience so far shows that it's not economical to do as you propose. It appears to be more economical to have farm areas with (sustainable) ag practices and ship the food to living areas/cities, even with the extra transport costs. Is there justification for paying people a living wage to work on a farm? What about $20/hour plus access to good quality nationalized health care? FWIW, there's also no justification to make a human work under a merciless boss. That is, your statement, which uses the word "make", implies a lack of job mobility and lack of social safety systems for the jobless more than something intrinsic to the job itself.