3 ms·
>Do you see anybody else there telling the person what to do? Is there some "eternal soul" that should have been informed to make the final decision? Obviously
by Barrin92 8y ago
>Do you see anybody else there telling the person what to do? Is there some "eternal soul" that should have been informed to make the final decision?
Obviously not, but commonly when people refer to so called 'free will', they don't just mean to imply that you, as a physical entity carry out things by your own volition, it is taken to mean that you consciously deliberate on your choices and have some insight into your own decision making.
These experiments suggests that the actual decision making happens at a much more secluded, black box like level.
Free will, in a meaningful sense, is taken to mean 'rational control', not just 'that guy over there acts in some way because his brain commands him to', because that's true almost by definition if you exclude religious explanations.
- root_axis 8y agoI don't see how any of that negates the idea of rational control in the sense that we commonly understand it. The series of physical events in the brain that lead to a decision are not subject to an out of band process that can override the final conclusion; it doesn't seem surprising that there is a delay between the unconscious processes that underpin our rational thoughts and the eventual culmination of a decision, IMO the opposite would actually be the surprising result (i.e. our conscious mind is not a supervenient product of our unconscious brain and supporting biological processes)
- coldtea 8y ago>Obviously not, but commonly when people refer to so called 'free will', they don't just mean to imply that you, as a physical entity carry out things by your own volition, it is taken to mean that you consciously deliberate on your choices and have some insight into your own decision making. Well, it's both: as people we can consciously deliberate on our choices for months, torment ourselves at a very conscious level, express it out to others who couldn't care less, listen to moody EMO music, even write lyrics about our predicaments before we make a choice. But we can also make some much easier decisions using our pre-conscious processing. And that might involve deliberation too -- it certainly involves prior experiences and stimuli. That's orthogonal to whether free will exists or not, though, and people saying that such pre-conscious choices it's proof free will doesn't exist are wrong. There's no necessity that free will has to be expressible as conscious deliberation. Just that it comes "freely" from the person. There might be lots of conscious deliberation behind those "non-conscious" decisions too. Free will might very well not exist, but not for that reason. We are ourselves, the whole time, sub-conscious or conscious. One's self doesn't resolve to just the "voice 'speaking' in our thoughts".