4 ms·
> It's not about dilligence, but practicality - there is no other way to wipe an iPhone but "completely" or "not at all". Not being able to do something proper
by Silhouette 16y ago
> It's not about dilligence, but practicality - there is no other way to wipe an iPhone but "completely" or "not at all".
Not being able to do something properly is not an excuse for doing it badly and causing serious damage to someone as a result.
In this case, if an employer cannot (a) allow an employee iPhone to connect to their mail store and (b) secure their own data appropriately without also (c) compromising the employee's, then they should not permit that access in the first place. They should provide the employee with a dedicated device, at company expense, over which the company can have whatever control it requires.
- tptacek 16y agoThat sounds like it makes life better for everybody. People who would rather use iPhones for corp mail than 3-year-old Blackberries, and who accept that the tradeoff for using them is potential "nuke from orbit", can't... so you can avoid having to think about whether to give your IT department that power. Everybody wins!
- Silhouette 16y agoIt is obvious from the fact that we are discussing the original article at all that this issue is more complicated than you make out. I already addressed the underlying issue you raise in my original reply; it was point #1. Perhaps you would care to further the debate by replying there, instead of resorting to sarcasm and mockery?
- jodrellblank 16y agoNot being able to do something properly is not an excuse for doing it badly Yes it really is. I'm not a builder but if I had to shelter from weather I would make a shelter. And my excuse for it being a low quality shelter is that I can't make a perfect one. And that would be better than nothing because at least I wouldn't die. Your idealism is idealistic but not helpful. If iPhones couldn't read company email they wouldn't be as useful or as popular. If they could do so, but only by enforcing a horrible dual-personality where you had to manually switch between contexts they wouldn't sell as well or be as popular or useful. If they share data they are easier to use and more popular but not as easy to secure. You say "not being able to do something properly" without addressing the fact that there is no accepted "proper" way to do it. They didn't ignore the proper way because they were lazy or stupid. Exchange email started on Windows Mobile devices for office use. That it has spread to consumer phones means the assumptions under which it was designed no longer hold. and causing serious damage to someone as a result. 1) As far as we are told, no damage at all happened to her, she didn't even get lost after losing her navigation system. 2) We don't know that /serious/ damage happened to her. 3) The more serious the potential damage, the more important it was for her to have a backup of her important data and a backup of her important systems. There's no getting around this tradeoff. 4) The more serious the potential damage, the more important it is for her to understand what she is doing when making changes to her device and not blankly follow instructions to hook it up to things willy nilly. Your second paragraph is a "person should be protected from all harm they don't understand by an all seeing overlord" argument, and it falls down where anyone else wants to do anything else or accept a different risk profile than uninformed easily panicked J. Bloggs.
- Silhouette 16y ago>> Not being able to do something properly is not an excuse for doing it badly > Yes it really is. I don't really know what I can say to this post. You have somehow turned this whole incident into the victim's fault, mitigating the consequences of the company IT staff's mistake into the victim's responsibility, and my argument that it is not reasonable for an employer to introduce such a drastic facility to destroy an employee's personal property without giving the employee fair warning into some unbounded "no-one should be responsible for anything" argument. We live in two different universes.
- jodrellblank 16y agoI haven't turned it ino that, I see it as that - apart from the fault bit. Nobody is at fault. The user didn't understand, the phone and email system isn't perfect, the IT staff made a mistake. These things happen. It doesn't need government legislation, lawyers and compensation. Shit happens. What do we do differently in future? We could try educating people about IT, but people don't care about IT. We could try legislation, but that costs time and money and makes life less pleasant. We could try not getting upset when everything isn't perfect and ideal. That helps. What makes you think the employee didn't get fair warning?
- Silhouette 16y ago> Nobody is at fault. ?! The corporate IT people screwed up and issued a data-loss command they apparently had neither reason nor authorisation to issue. Someone's personal property was completely wiped as a result. We don't know how much valuable personal data was on that phone, but it could have held e-mails, photographs, etc. They could have been important, have great sentimental value, even have been evidence in a legal action (e.g., photos taken after a road accident). In any case, this is clear cut negligence. The phone wipe might not have been deliberate, but the damage was done and it is absolutely clear who was at fault. > What makes you think the employee didn't get fair warning? Well, for one thing, this: "It was my account, in my name [and] I'd paid all the bills," Stanton says. "It didn't make any sense to me that somehow work could get through AT&T, who I thought controlled my phone, and could completely disable the phone and the account." Does that sound like the employee was properly informed to you?