8 ms·
Bruce Schneier: It's time for technologists to become lawmakers
- gist 8y agoUmm, you first Bruce... Add: Sorry don't mean to add so little. Just feel it's a case of someone standing on the sidelines who makes a living writing (and that is what Bruce does, right) pushing others to do what they don't want to do. And to those who say 'well it's good that he brings the issue out in the open' sure that is the case. But it might be better if he is actually willing to carry through on his suggestions or at least talk about someone who he convinced to follow his idea.
- fergbrain 8y agoIf the goal was to pick one person to run for office, then Bruce would be a good candidate. But that’s not the goal. He’s advocating for lots of candidates, many of whom will likely need to start running at local levels first. If Bruce were to run for candidacy it could signal to other technologists that they don’t need to do anything — which is the opposite of what’s needed. Instead, I’d like to see Bruce offer to act in an advisory/mentoring role for the technologists/engineers who do run.
- gist 8y agoI think there is also this misconception that politics is about being smart or being right. That is far from the case. Politics is the art of compromise and selling others on what you believe in. As such the wrong type of personality and approach can fail miserably. And the right approach and personality can win big time even if they have no clue or the wrong or bad ideas. You also have to be willing to go along and made deals that on the surface seem like bad ideas to do. If just so that others politicians will pay you back when you want to get something done. Know how to play the game.
- jacobush 8y agoOr win miserably, which is worse. (A play on words, but you know what I mean.)
- cwingrav 8y agoI love the idea, but many of the intrinsic rewards for technologists in tech, don’t exist in politics. Many issues can be solved fairly easily if we calm down, take a look at experiences and data, and apply solutions that have been shown effective. Technologists like solving problems; problem solved. Politics however have so many other, non-solution/problem based variables, that are very, very hard to overcome. While I agree with Bruce, we first need to recapture our politics for the people in the country, not politicians.
- ddebernardy 8y ago> Politics however have so many other, non-solution/problem based variables, that are very, very hard to overcome. While I agree with Bruce, we first need to recapture our politics for the people in the country, not politicians. The main way to do that is for you to get involved. If you do not, someone else who might not see that as a problem will, and the problem you despise will continue. Edit: It's not even hard to do, if you're dreading to meet people. There's an app out there that (exclusively) helps conservatives organize grassroots movements and increase their voter turnout. Last I checked there still wasn't any liberal or libertarian equivalent. If you're into either of the latter, you can get involved and help your favorite political flavor build an equivalent app.
- cwingrav 8y agoEvidence shows getting involved has little impact. Only money. This quip we always talk about is not true when you analyze the data. You’re going to hear more and more about this in the coming years: https://scholar.princeton.edu/sites/default/files/mgilens/files/gilens_and_page_2014_-testing_theories_of_american_politics.doc.pdf https://scholar.princeton.edu/sites/default/files/mgilens/fi...
- linkmotif 8y agoLawmakers are elected so yeah good luck.
- unnouinceput 8y agoExactly's Bruce idea as well, as a technologist go run for office...start locally then go up the ladder. And create laws that you know will stem the tide of apple/google/facebook to trample your privacy as they see fit.
- linkmotif 8y agoTech people don’t resonate with the electorate. WWE resonates with the electorate.
- externalreality 8y agoPerhaps our voting system should change such that technologists votes/opinions count more on technological issues rather than just making them lawmakers. What good is a computer technologist's opinion regarding anything other than computer tech? That is why I think many lawmaking bodies are broken to begin with. The people who have the votes on most matters are mostly not the ones whose opinion should be counting?
- wjnc 8y agoMy opinion in short (nofi): Anyone with decent skills, a love for getting things done and some need for privacy needs to stay as far away from politics as possible. I've tried it when young and naive. The 'thinking for others' part is addictive, plus it's quite the thrill that people actually vote for you. But it comes with quite the cost. No privacy, death threats, the constant bending over backwards stretching your true beliefs for the party line. So many politicians are abusers of substances, prone to corruption and generally mentally unstable that I don't buy the line 'we need different politicians' anymore. We need different politics. I have no clue how to get there though and advocate a quite life for anyone. Not necessarily 9-5, but something with clear boundaries and where one is not the focal point for any lunatic. I'd make the same point of not becoming CEO though.
- avmich 8y agoTechnologists, unlike politicians, have a luxury of creating a system and offering it to others, without asking for trust (in form of election or other) or promising doing some specific work (to support the system, to use it etc.) If the system is good, others will use it; otherwise they won't. As I understand it, Schneier's idea is to ask technologists to work on systems solving - even partially - problems which we see today in the society. Even partial solution can help those whose job is to, in general, govern, i.e. politicians - as well as hired bureaucrats.
- FakeComments 8y ago> We need different politics. I agree — and a place technologists can make an impact with a little more obscurity is in the infrastructure for politics. The problems with politics aren’t merely a technical solution, but it does seem like the advent of mass media and computers has changed some things about politics — which means that a change in the technical mechanisms can change the process and outcomes. If you think about the math, each represenative stands for about 750,000 people on average. About half to three quarters of their constituents will be working aged, so 375,000. About 1 in 100 will be motivated enough to put a few hours into helping now and then, so 3,750. You figure “now and then” really means “once a year”, but you need help once a month — 375. Maybe 1 in 10 really has something useful to say, so 38. But the point is when you’re talking about major legislation, it seems like you should be able to recruit a few dozen to a few hundred people to put eyes on the text. By hosting a public repository across districts, you can probably reliably get a few hundred to a thousand volunteers to mark up legislation (or help with ML based scanners). I’ve long thought a website which joined law markup/comments, vote tracking, and candidate writing would be largely effective — it drops the amount of effort required for a citizen to express effective oversight, and collates information back to you during elections.
- tomc1985 8y agoHe's a little late isn't he? As little of five years ago tech had a lot more goodwill than it does now. In democratic societies we techies probably have more of an uphill battle than others, because the few of us in charge of companies cannot behave properly
- avmich 8y agoSatoshi Nakamoto isn't known as a CEO of a powerful corporation, but his work had quite an influence over last ~10 years. We can do something similar. Remember, say, how Skype was created? Or WhatsApp? Or Paxos? BitTorrent?
- elcomet 8y agoBitcoin had marginal influence among a group of believers. It didn't have a real world impact (yet ?).
- avmich 8y agoDepends on what impact to consider real world. Bunch of people managed to transfer money from their countries abroad using bitcoin. Lots of papers were written studying blockchains. Some financial and other organizations considered and, I believe, at some point deployed systems modeled on Bitcoin technology. Maybe that's not enough to consider it "real world impact", but I suspect more than one person's life was noticeably affected by using Bitcoins.
- ddebernardy 8y ago> Back in the 1950s, tech and policy didn’t really interact, unless it had to do with something like nuclear weapons or the space program. Today, tech and policy are intertwined, Schneier said. > “Today, technology makes de facto policy that’s far more influential than any law,” he said. “Law is forever trying to catch up with technology. And it’s no longer sustainable for technology and policy to be in different worlds.” Isn't that something of a misreading of late 19th and 20th history? Just about every decade in the late 19th and the 20th century was part of an ongoing telecoms, media, and IT boom. There were the telegraph, telephony and the fax, satellite communications, the internet, usenet, mobile telephony and SMS, internet forums and chat; radio, TV, streaming and social networks; typewriters, mechanical counting machines, transistors, microchips, mainframes, PCs, smartphones; etc. It's just wave after wave after wave after wave, with every decade or two adding some major development in one form or another. Sometimes what was happening required lawmaker attention. Laws and regulation followed every single time -- if only eventually. It's not entirely clear to me, apart from scale, how the problems we face today are that much different than, say, those that were on a would-be legislator's mind when radio became mainstream or when TV news became a thing. Bruce's points are most welcome and valid, but I wouldn't be surprised if a historian were able to dig up people making similar points (at least) since radio has been around. (Edit: And possibly since Gutenberg's printing press became mainstream.)
- UncleMeat 8y agoYeah that sentence is egregiously incorrect. Technology and policy have been intertwined for as long as we have had states. This is a clear example of somebody not trained in history just winging it when making historical claims. Heck, the specific technologies that Schneier cares about (related to communication and privacy) have been tightly coupled with policy for like 600 years. Way back when postal routes where just becoming a thing you already have state leaders and bureaucrats writing about how technologies like ciphers cause problems and enacting policies to ensure that states had the power they wanted over private communications.
- frozenport 8y agoAn astute observer would note that it also a case why technology advocates should not become lawmakers.
- bane 8y agoI absolutely understand the sentiment, but if you've ever seen explosive arguments over trivial technological decisions, you'd never want technologists working in an environment where sacrificial compromises are the rule du jour.
- dogma1138 8y agoI think the first thing to do in the US is to bring back the CRS to what it was supposed and more important needs to be, it’s current budget is only 100 million which is laughable considering how much lobbiest can spend in DC. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congressional_Research_Service https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Congressional_Research_Servi... Having an independent and impartial think tank that can brief law makers on the issues they are facing is more important that having people with STEM degrees in the lagislstive branch.
- sleepysysadmin 8y ago1 thing is for sure. The tech revolution is underway and it will be the technical people who will own the world. The caveat of this is that your average non-tech worker will hate tech. This will be 'robots stealing our jerbs' x10. Tech workers wont be able to get into office.