4 ms·
Instead of outright banning them, why not require a strict maximum dB level rating (in other words as tested by an independent lab). Personally I’m in favor of
by mc32 8y ago
Instead of outright banning them, why not require a strict maximum dB level rating (in other words as tested by an independent lab).
Personally I’m in favor of limiting noise output rather than outright banning.
Otherwise it’s tyrannical for a minority to tell the majority what they may and may not do.
- chrisseaton 8y agoThen it’s much harder to enforce. It goes from ‘oi no leafblowers mate’ to getting an independent official with a calibrated tool and all sorts of faff. Plus the article is more about pollution than noise so limiting noise doesn’t help with that does it.
- muststopmyths 8y ago>The acoustic study found that in a densely settled neighborhood, a gas-powered blower rated at, say, 75 decibels of noisiness can affect up to 15 times as many households as a battery-powered blower with the same 75-decibel rating.
- mc32 8y agoThe motor of engine is part of the noise, the other is the fans pushing air through, their speed and pitch affect noise levels too, so even an electric leaf blower can be loud and uncomfortable.
- mund2ne 8y agoYeah, but not the same kind of loud and uncomfortable, as anyone who has actually heard these things in person knows immediately.
- beardedwizard 8y agoAh I see, now you get to arbitrarily decide what noise is annoying for others, because only one kind bothers you.
- hedora 8y agoThere’s also the dust from the ground, which, at best, contains allergens and can also cause asthma attacks. In cities, it will also contain carcinogens that were shed by cars, giving them another chance to be inhaled. So, if you want to design a quiet, outdoor HEPA vacuum, go for it!
- toofy 8y agoBy banning 2-cycle leafblowers and encouraging people to switch to electric powered they're knocking out two problems at once--the awful noise and the ridiculous amount of nasty stuff 2-cycle motors spew all over into our environments. The majority can still have their electric leafblowers.
- lozenge 8y agoIt would amount to the same thing. The noise is an inherent part of the design of the two stroke engine. Isn't the tyranny the leaf blowers creating noise for everybody around them?
- plussed_reader 8y agoThis was addressed in the article; the overall sound output was much more dense in the equivalent two stroke versus a battery powered options at 75dB. The lower frequencies generated in the two stroke options output link to human biological issues over time as well as the distance traveling issue of the sound at the heart of the article.
- koboll 8y ago>Otherwise it’s tyrannical for a minority to tell the majority what they may and may not do. Your liberty to blow leaves ends where damage to my hearing and breathing begins. When the minority is imposing direct negative health effects on the majority, it's not tyranny to prevent them from harming everyone else.