3 ms·
Or should we not have hastily trained low-competence pilots flying around?
by tinus_hn 8y ago
Or should we not have hastily trained low-competence pilots flying around?
- cjbprime 8y agoThe pilot on this plane appears to have been expert, flying for the airline for around a decade.
- unionemployee 8y agoI don't think that's avoidable. The demand is too high right now. Personally, I'd like to see increased automation and "low-pilot" aircraft enter service.
- VLM 8y agoNote that we have decades of experience and skill at easily teaching basic stick and rudder flying skills, however deploying independent systems/automation analysts under emergency conditions is highly problematic and will likely result in more tragedies. I'm just saying its simpler, cheaper, and safer to deploy people who can troubleshoot simple flying systems rather than to deploy people who will have to debug untested and complicated automation systems on the fly. It would be the most extreme field service posting, ever. What we have here is an over optimization problem; we "have to" build unflyable aircraft to keep up with everyone elses level of recklessness to squeeze a couple more hyper-financialized pennies out of the system or be replaced by someone reckless enough to do it. Traditionally regulation helps in these situations. The aircraft of the future is far more likely to have networking and interconnected processors prohibited by law for safety reasons than to be an internet of things self-flying appliance. That would result in a nice simple, admittedly lower performance, far more reliable overall system. Non-networked non-interconnected control microprocessors seem safe enough so far, but making an infinitely complicated hyper optimized system seems in practice to result in planes falling out of the sky too often.
- CydeWeys 8y agoYou could make the same faulty argument to obviate the need for all safety features on everything. Safety is about defense in depth. Ideally we'd have all planes flown by perfect platonic human pilots, but such a thing does not actually exist. All people are flawed (some more than others), and we should design technology to be resilient in the face of the inevitable human failings to the fullest extent possible, especially when lives are on the line. Boeing has simply failed to do so here.
- JshWright 8y ago> Ideally we'd have all planes flown by perfect platonic human pilots, but such a thing does not actually exist. Until we teach spherical cows to fly planes, that is...
- tinus_hn 8y agoYou could make this argument for a toaster or a word processor. If you’re talking about a flying vehicle carrying 158 people it’s no more than a poor excuse. The pilots ought to be competent and properly trained and only then you can start blaming the equipment.
- jeffdavis 8y agohttps://xkcd.com/293/ https://xkcd.com/293/
- rad_gruchalski 8y agoThe pilot had 8k+ hours of flight.