3 ms·
The idea that medieval people believed in a flat Earth is not true. The shape and approximate size of the Earth was knowm since ancient times (3rd century BC).
by iwr 16y ago
The idea that medieval people believed in a flat Earth is not true. The shape and approximate size of the Earth was knowm since ancient times (3rd century BC).
Columbus was not turned down at first because people believed he'd fall off the edge of the Earth; they knew he could not have possibly reached Asia, the distance was too great. It was only pure luck (finding America) that saved him. A venture capitalist in those times would have been rational not to buy into the expedition.
As for geocentrism, that has some merits. But note that Ptolemy and his followers were really hindered by a lack of good astronomical data. Using methods of those times, an epicyclical model of the planets was pretty accurate and could have been refined further. The model of Copernicus was deemed superior because it needed fewer epicycles to make the math right. The breakthrough came only after Kepler got the very accurate Huygens observations (taken over 20 years); after he had enough datapoints, he could come up with his famous laws.
And so, let's not blame the Ancients right away. They were not as ignorant as we may believe.
- fhars 16y agoReasonable people thought that the ocean (without america, there would be no separate atlantic and pacific ocean) was considerably smaller than it really is, not least due to the impossibility to reliably measure longitude, so they vastly overestimated the east-west extension of eurasia. Just look at the globes Behaim made in 1491-1493 (based on data by Pope Sixtus IV) which shows a really small ocean: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Behaim#The_Erdapfel http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Martin_Behaim#The_Erdapfel According to the best contemporary data, the investment would have been highly speculative (as all voyages across the sea), but not insanely so.
- brc 16y agoMaybe the flat earth theory was invoked as a polite way of telling Columbus no. In the same way that many investors never say no, they often say 'not right now'. The story must have had a kernel of truth to grow from.