3 ms·
This is just so completely wrong, it's hard to know where to start! You could start by not being a panicky reactionary mess about it. It is useful to be able
by jodrellblank 16y ago
This is just so completely wrong, it's hard to know where to start!
You could start by not being a panicky reactionary mess about it.
It is useful to be able to wipe a remote mobile device with access into a company computer system when it it is lost, compromised or in unfriendly hands.
From that follows that software developers made it possible and providers made it available and employers think it reasonable to use on any mobile device which agreed to access their servers, personal or not.
It isn't illegal with "horrific penalties" - why would it be?
- Silhouette 16y ago> It isn't illegal with "horrific penalties" - why would it be? This whole discussion is about a company wiping an employee's personal phone, by accident and for no reason, including cutting off an active call and disrupting the navigation system they were using. Do you really not see why this behaviour is unacceptable?
- jodrellblank 16y agoI really do not see why this behaviour is unacceptable. It cannot be unacceptable to have accidents. Or, you can choose to not accept it if you like but they will still happen. This was not a serious accident like a poisoning due to dodgy food labelling or a car crash or a bulldozer knocking her house down, and therefore it does not require legislation and it certainly does not require "horrific pentalties".
- Silhouette 16y agoBy your argument, should we not also abolish crimes such as manslaughter and causing death by careless driving, not permit any legal actions based on negligence, and generally absolve everyone of any responsibility for their actions even if those actions are both harmful and avoidable provided that they are not deliberate? If that is your position, then we have very different ethics here. > This was not a serious accident Several people in this discussion seem to bring that up, but as far as I can see we don't know either way. It is certainly possible that the same action could have caused loss of much personal data of sentimental and/or direct financial value, cut off communications at an important moment with all kinds of serious consequences, left a driver stranded with no navigation to get them back to familiar territory, etc. Even if that didn't happen in this particular case, it was pure luck.
- jodrellblank 16y agoBy your argument, should we not also abolish crimes such as manslaughter and causing death by careless driving Well, if you want to be silly about it, by your argument shouldn't we make mistakes illegal and then slaughter everyone because everyone makes mistakes? That is not my argument. You see where I said "an erased phone is not a serious problem therefore it doesn't need legislationg" Where did that give you the idea that I think manslaughter is OK? It is certainly possible that the same action could have caused loss of much personal data of sentimental and/or direct financial value, cut off communications at an important moment with all kinds of serious consequences Even if it did cause those things, those are not serious consequences. Problems serious enough for legislation are things which are likely to result in a high rate of injury and death, or be long term dangerous/injurious to a lot of people (eg. shoddy building codes). If you really want nationwide legislation forbidding companies from letting employees use personal phones to read email because they might lose their only copy of sentimental pictures, and prefer that to suggesting the person have a second copy of their pictures, then we have incredibly different views on how life is and should ideally be.