3 ms·
Regarding the last point, it's not just a choice between "sell or give away as CC", "I don't want people to use my photos, or at least not without my individual
by detaro 8y ago
Regarding the last point, it's not just a choice between "sell or give away as CC", "I don't want people to use my photos, or at least not without my individual permission" is a common mindset too.
- ghaff 8y agoI guess my feeling about that is "Then why would you license as CC?" It feels a little bit like wanting to license your software under an open source license but requiring that people obtain your permission before using it. [ADDED: I do agree that many people have a reflexive desire to control things that are "theirs" or at least to keep others from making money off of it. I'm just saying that if many/most of the people who want to use Flickr for free thought about it rationally, they'd come to the conclusion that they're not really losing anything by licensing under CC.] After all, people can already contact you and ask for your permission to use a photo (for a payment or otherwise). Organizations have done it with me lots of times. (In my experience, many want to get explicit permission even if something is licensed under CC.) To be clear, there's absolutely nothing wrong with reserving all your rights to something you've created. But it's not open source/Creative Commons if you do so.
- lixtra 8y ago> Then why would you license as CC? Your criticism should point to CC itself then. The reason to use it is that it takes a few bytes to express your license which would otherwise a lawyer to consult you. And on the other hand a potential user immediately understands whether the license is appropriate for her.
- ghaff 8y agoI don't have a criticism of CC. (Well, I do of non-commercial and no-derivatives, but that's a separate discussion.) If someone's willing to share their creative output in an open source way, CC-BY-SA, CC-BY, and CC0 are perfectly fine licenses. If someone's not, then they should just reserve rights.
- jeena 8y agoWhat license should I use if I want to make it possible for podcasts to include my music into their compilations as is, because I have a artistic vision which I don't want to have destroyed, but not for Hip-Hop artists to chop it and use it in a different context because it isn't how I envision my art being used? Or what If I want a gallery to be able to print my pictures and show it as is, again because I put in a lot of thought and work into the coherence of my artistic vision, but I don't want video artists to chop it and reuse it in a weird setting? I think those are legitimate use cases for a license.
- ghaff 8y agoThat's the ND (NoDerivs) variant of Creative Commons. I do sorta get the "artistic vision" aspect of ND use although it's counter to the remix idea that was pretty central to the Creative Commons concept in the first place.
- detaro 8y ago> I guess my feeling about that is "Then why would you license as CC?" I was responding to "why most people who don't want to pay wouldn't just license their photos CC" and the following bit - wanting to be paid isn't the only reason not to use CC or any other open license.
- ghaff 8y agoI don't really disagree--hence my addendum--but I'd still argue that, in many (but certainly not all) cases, the desire for control is rooted in a perhaps implicit suspicion that a work might have at least some potential value, if not to you, to someone else who might "unfairly" profit off it.
- chrismeller 8y agoOr I just don’t want anyone using a picture of my kids at the beach because I think that’d be creepy?
- meruru 8y agoThat doesn't sound like something you should be posting to Flickr though.
- ghaff 8y agoI think if you don't want random people seeing and using some photo, you're probably better off not sharing it publicly rather than depending on a license to protect it.
- chrismeller 8y agoI don’t disagree, but I was pointing out that there are other reasons people wouldn’t want to license their work as CC just because it’s on Flickr other than potential future monetary gain.