3 ms·
When did we have free markets? Because I can't think of any time. No, we can't 'go back'. Cities are more efficient than what you propose. Apartment buildings
by eesmith 8y ago
When did we have free markets? Because I can't think of any time.
No, we can't 'go back'. Cities are more efficient than what you propose. Apartment buildings need less heat. Water treatment and district heating are cheaper than individual systems. There's also more things to do in cities. In theory cities can be built on land which is not good for farming, but the sprawl of Chicago shows that people will pay more for city land than farming land.
The number I've heard for land area is about 5 acres per person. See https://www.primalsurvivor.net/much-land-need-self-sufficient/ https://www.primalsurvivor.net/much-land-need-self-sufficien... . And that's if you have good land, water, and growing season. I've only heard 1 acre for land with some of the very intensive methods like hydroponics and vertical growing. These require more equipment (made elsewhere) and labor. Most people don't want to be subsistence farmers.
As your user id is 'jelliclesfarm', I assume you are a farmer. My g'father was farmer in Michigan, but that's because he was poor and land was cheap. The farm work fed the family while the cash money came from his also working as a machinist.
I don't see how more automation would help achieve the goals you want. Quite the contrary. Factory farming is successful because of automating farms.
As an example from the article: "In these industrial farming units, pigs, cows and chickens are crammed by the thousand into rows of barns. Many units are semi-automated, with feeding run by computer and the animals watched by video, with periodic visits by workers who drive between several operations."
For another example: Investors buy the land, and they have tractors and combines that you can run by computer,” she said. “They’ll hire somebody to sit in a little office somewhere and run that stuff off the computer and farm the land that way.
That is, we could easily be worse off (if your goal is a low-density/village-centered society) by pushing more farm automation.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoI come from a very populous country and I am not impressed by the arguments made by high density proponents. In my lived experience, it degrades quality of life. As a small acreage farmer, I see that the market forces don’t work for me due to economies of scale. Or lack thereof. Having said that..the water and soil are really abused in rural areas. Ag must be distributed and especially in sub optimal land rather than prime fertile land. Good land should be returned back to nature as we reforest and bring ecological balance. Now we have soilless Ag and indoor Ag and CEA. If every urban center is food self sufficient, we can remove ‘farm regions’ and help restore habitat and bring ecological balance. We need grasslands more than trees and forests to sequester carbon. If people didn’t farm and food production is automated, they can do more productive work. Humans can be trained to do higher skill jobs. And fulfilling work that doesn’t crush them. Every ‘industry’ is detrimental. It consumes more than it contributes. With farming(crops, not cafos in the original article) as an example, it’s not just the carbon released due to tilling but also the loss of habitat and erosion and chemicals and water. Add to it the distribution of food from farm gate to food hubs and the entire supply chain. And then the transportation and the refrigeration of perishables. Even the workers who need to drive to work and all the energy they expend. The math just doesn’t work out. How much are you spending in terms of calories and $ for a head of lettuce? The cost is too much for what we get back in return. It makes no sense.
- eesmith 8y agoYou did not say when we had the free markets you want to return to. You switched from "can we go" back to "in my lived experience." These are two different things. I observe that most people disagree with your experience. But that's okay - we aren't all the same. But in order to reach your goals you're going to need to do a lot of convincing. You wrote about "soilless Ag and indoor Ag and CEA". My points haven't changed concerning the need for expensive equipment and higher labor. I'll note that you originally wrote "self sufficiency" but now say "food self sufficient". Who makes the plastic and the light sources? Where does the power for the lights come from? In essence, how do you get the costs down such that it best the natural advantages of (say) growing food in California and shipping it by rail to the rest of the US? You write: "If every urban center is food self sufficient" Population of NYC = 8,622,698. Size = 784 km2. That's 0.02 acres per person. People love living in New York. People move (from farms even!) to New York. What do you think would convince most New Yorkers to move somewhere else for food self sufficiency? "they can do more productive work" .. Certainly. That's what every factory farm system always says. That's been the mantra of automation for the last few centuries. Funnily enough, all those profits go to the capital owners, and in doing so has lead to critiques of the free market, including by Marx. Who gets to say what "fulfilling work" means? The stage environment around Broadway, or the tango culture of Buenos Aires, could not exist if we all lived in small towns like you propose. Isn't that also fulfilling? There are all sorts of things which big cities have that smaller ones simply cannot. I am mostly only concerned with replying to your 'self sufficient ‘village’' question. My critique does not mean that there isn't a huge negative environmental and cultural impact of current agricultural practices, nor does it excuse the dependency of modern ag on cheap oil, which appears to be what your last paragraph is about.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoEnumerating points: 1. Free market economy exists in Asia. Singapore, for example..is run like a corporation. I want to say it’s a free market economy but it’s only partly free markets. Because of its resource limitations, there is some govt interventions. It is not self sufficient and yet it functions smoothly. So that would be the model closest to what’s in my mind of a free market economy. 2. We are ‘going back’ on a timeline of self sufficiency. A hunter gatherer didn’t have markets. There was no supply chain or cold chain or transportation. They ate when they hunted and foraged the rest of the time leaving a lot of free time. Of course, I am not saying that we ought to go back to being hunter gatherers ..I am just saying that the world has not become smaller physically but the resources have shrunk. It’s the physical dimensions of resources, water, energy etc that must be localized and where we ought to be self sufficient. My ‘lived experience’ is high density highly populous urban experience. 3. There is no doubt that current Ag practices have to change. Most of it has to go indoors. 4. I also feel that high density living has its advantages as long as the resources needed for the tightly packed people are also accessible. You mention NYC. It has a good transport network and parks and ingress/egress and homes and offices and shopping. So even though it’s high density, it’s liveable. I live in a Silicon Valley suburb that is transforming into high density and just high density housing. And it’s awful. Because we have traffic issues and no public transport. The city isn’t walkable and there is no shopping or entertainment and people who work here travel from far off and those who live here work elsewhere. It’s an unformed high density failed city with no ecosystem. There is a troubling trend (here in California and in urban hearts) where housing is being concentrated with high density goals without providing infrastructure or an eco system. It’s crippling. The local economy suffers..local businesses suffer...infrastructure degrades faster and schools become over crowded. To me..it’s a bad example of high density ..nyc is a workable model of high density. Mobility and roads will be the key to how successful a city can be..and for that we rely on fossil fuel. But think 100 years down the timeline or a time when fossil fuels becomes less available ..cities may become isolated and they would need to be self sufficient modules that are networked to other city clusters and yet even operating independently, they don’t collapse. 5. I dont worry too much about the cost of technology or labour to create technology. As far as I am concerned, money is something we can print. We will never run out of it. The detail is in the macro and micro economic word wrangling. Resources ..on the other hand..are finite. Fossil fuel is finite..water, top soil ..the space around us. Regardless of how high density can be packaged as ‘sustainable’, we still need resources to maintain every warm body. A lettuce grown in your hydroponic or soil kitchen garden takes less resources than one that is grown 3000 miles away and is transported and refrigerated and sold in a store and then people are paid to sell it to you and you have to bring it back home. And by this time, the lettuce is likely 10 days from the time it was harvested. It’s a ridiculous amount of energy spent on lettuce you can grow from seed and pick whenever you want. So why don’t we do this? Why can’t we grow at least half of our food at home? We have a laundry machine and dishwasher and fridge all built in to the house. Why not a hydroponic cupboard that is part of the home construction? Why not a roof top garden or a attached temperature controlled greenhouse like it’s another bedroom or a bathroom. The marginal cost isn’t a lot but energy savings is enormous. 6. Further..think at a larger scale. If a city can grow all it’s herbs and nightshades and greens but only needs to buy grains and nuts and fruits from outside markets, it’s all the more self sufficient. Every city can do what it does best and relies on outside clusters for what it lacks. 7. I have a farm. There is no justification to make a human being work under the merciless sun..bending and picking fruit or lettuce for eight hours a day for minimum wage. We are not doing anyone any favors. Its borderline disgusting to me and highly illogical and unnecessary.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoFor what it’s worth..my thoughts on the matter is clusters of 200-250 people who are self sufficient units. And each unit cooperatively lives with their cluster. And maybe 10-12 clusters form a larger ‘village’ and another 10-12 villages form a town. I like decentralized local governments. It seems more efficient. Thoughts?
- eesmith 8y agoWhat does "efficient" mean? Who produces all the plastic and LED lights for the farms? Will there be smart phones produced by companies like Foxconn with 800,000 employees, and if so, how will they live? What does "efficient" mean to you? Is it a measure of people per acre of land? Is it a measure of self-worth? Is it the amount of vacation/personal time each person gets? Your definition elsewhere uses "quality of life", so how do you express that in a way that most people will agree with? Because for me, I live in the center a small city of 60,000 people and I really enjoy that there are scores of restaurants, eight or so grocery stores, lovely parks and walking trails, cafes, a library, my doctor, swimming pool, and more, within about 15 minutes walking. I don't see that diversity of opportunities happening in your concept. Your minimum size for a village of 20,000 people at 1 acre per person is 81 sq. km. That's 9km x 9km or a circle with radius 5km. In fact, they just built a new apartment complex at the other end of downtown with 177 apartments - or roughly the population of one of your clusters. It fits in a city block.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoI want to think about this before penning my views. I enjoy ‘building’ cities or rather city concepts. And I have many of them. I am trying to think which one would be suitable for sharing here. I need some time to choose one to share.
- eesmith 8y agoThere is a long history of utopian city design. Based on what you wrote, your views seem aligned with agrarianism. Quoting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agrarianism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Agrarianism > Agrarianism is a social philosophy or political philosophy which values rural society as superior to urban society and the independent farmer as superior to the paid worker, and sees farming as a way of life that can shape the ideal social values. As such, you would probably like Plat of the City of Zion, from Joseph Smith, founder of Mormonism and the Latter Day Saint movement. Quoting https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/plat-of-zion/ https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/plat-of-zion/ : > This imagined city would be as populous as New York or Philadelphia were at the time, and would offer the best parts of a city—infrastructure, education, and community—but without vice and crime. Joseph Smith thought this could be achieved by giving residents lots of space; it would essentially be a rural city. Within the large blocks, each church member would have a plot of land for fruit trees and vegetable gardens, along with a home, which Smith imagined as the essential piece of the urban fabric.