3 ms·
I wonder what would be the optimal size for a (mostly)self sufficient ‘village’..with enough for themselves and then to trade? Can we go back to the times when
by jelliclesfarm 8y ago
I wonder what would be the optimal size for a (mostly)self sufficient ‘village’..with enough for themselves and then to trade? Can we go back to the times when we can have free markets AND a limited amount of protectionism AND self sufficiency? Or is that contradictory.
If 1 square mile is 640 acres. Let’s say it can support 600 individuals or 150-200 families...can we stop expanding at that point and rather than have dense cities, simply add another square mile to form another self sufficient town ..all interconnected and clustered..with local governance and self sufficiency.
(I am speaking generally and not particularly about CAFOs)
I am not romanticizing going back to feudal farming economy..but just borrowing their structure and applying it to our modern times to not stress resources and not create pockets of dense urban towns and then urban sprawl and then rural boondocks.
I could be wrong but at least with soil Ag, economies of scale don’t seem to matter with full automation as we rely on less labour costs. The supply chain is a problem and it is likely people will a little more for food. But we already way too little for food and commodity Ag is subsidized. We can’t be worse off by automating farms and making them smaller and doing away with economies of scale.
- eesmith 8y agoWhen did we have free markets? Because I can't think of any time. No, we can't 'go back'. Cities are more efficient than what you propose. Apartment buildings need less heat. Water treatment and district heating are cheaper than individual systems. There's also more things to do in cities. In theory cities can be built on land which is not good for farming, but the sprawl of Chicago shows that people will pay more for city land than farming land. The number I've heard for land area is about 5 acres per person. See https://www.primalsurvivor.net/much-land-need-self-sufficient/ https://www.primalsurvivor.net/much-land-need-self-sufficien... . And that's if you have good land, water, and growing season. I've only heard 1 acre for land with some of the very intensive methods like hydroponics and vertical growing. These require more equipment (made elsewhere) and labor. Most people don't want to be subsistence farmers. As your user id is 'jelliclesfarm', I assume you are a farmer. My g'father was farmer in Michigan, but that's because he was poor and land was cheap. The farm work fed the family while the cash money came from his also working as a machinist. I don't see how more automation would help achieve the goals you want. Quite the contrary. Factory farming is successful because of automating farms. As an example from the article: "In these industrial farming units, pigs, cows and chickens are crammed by the thousand into rows of barns. Many units are semi-automated, with feeding run by computer and the animals watched by video, with periodic visits by workers who drive between several operations." For another example: Investors buy the land, and they have tractors and combines that you can run by computer,” she said. “They’ll hire somebody to sit in a little office somewhere and run that stuff off the computer and farm the land that way. That is, we could easily be worse off (if your goal is a low-density/village-centered society) by pushing more farm automation.
- jelliclesfarm 8y agoI come from a very populous country and I am not impressed by the arguments made by high density proponents. In my lived experience, it degrades quality of life. As a small acreage farmer, I see that the market forces don’t work for me due to economies of scale. Or lack thereof. Having said that..the water and soil are really abused in rural areas. Ag must be distributed and especially in sub optimal land rather than prime fertile land. Good land should be returned back to nature as we reforest and bring ecological balance. Now we have soilless Ag and indoor Ag and CEA. If every urban center is food self sufficient, we can remove ‘farm regions’ and help restore habitat and bring ecological balance. We need grasslands more than trees and forests to sequester carbon. If people didn’t farm and food production is automated, they can do more productive work. Humans can be trained to do higher skill jobs. And fulfilling work that doesn’t crush them. Every ‘industry’ is detrimental. It consumes more than it contributes. With farming(crops, not cafos in the original article) as an example, it’s not just the carbon released due to tilling but also the loss of habitat and erosion and chemicals and water. Add to it the distribution of food from farm gate to food hubs and the entire supply chain. And then the transportation and the refrigeration of perishables. Even the workers who need to drive to work and all the energy they expend. The math just doesn’t work out. How much are you spending in terms of calories and $ for a head of lettuce? The cost is too much for what we get back in return. It makes no sense.
- eesmith 8y agoYou did not say when we had the free markets you want to return to. You switched from "can we go" back to "in my lived experience." These are two different things. I observe that most people disagree with your experience. But that's okay - we aren't all the same. But in order to reach your goals you're going to need to do a lot of convincing. You wrote about "soilless Ag and indoor Ag and CEA". My points haven't changed concerning the need for expensive equipment and higher labor. I'll note that you originally wrote "self sufficiency" but now say "food self sufficient". Who makes the plastic and the light sources? Where does the power for the lights come from? In essence, how do you get the costs down such that it best the natural advantages of (say) growing food in California and shipping it by rail to the rest of the US? You write: "If every urban center is food self sufficient" Population of NYC = 8,622,698. Size = 784 km2. That's 0.02 acres per person. People love living in New York. People move (from farms even!) to New York. What do you think would convince most New Yorkers to move somewhere else for food self sufficiency? "they can do more productive work" .. Certainly. That's what every factory farm system always says. That's been the mantra of automation for the last few centuries. Funnily enough, all those profits go to the capital owners, and in doing so has lead to critiques of the free market, including by Marx. Who gets to say what "fulfilling work" means? The stage environment around Broadway, or the tango culture of Buenos Aires, could not exist if we all lived in small towns like you propose. Isn't that also fulfilling? There are all sorts of things which big cities have that smaller ones simply cannot. I am mostly only concerned with replying to your 'self sufficient ‘village’' question. My critique does not mean that there isn't a huge negative environmental and cultural impact of current agricultural practices, nor does it excuse the dependency of modern ag on cheap oil, which appears to be what your last paragraph is about.