6 ms·
I'm not sure what is worse: - the fact that this is technically possible, - the fact that the software and service providers think it is appropriate to offer
by Silhouette 16y ago
I'm not sure what is worse:
- the fact that this is technically possible,
- the fact that the software and service providers think it is appropriate to offer the feature,
- the fact that some employers (such as the one in the article) actually think it is even slightly reasonable behaviour to use the feature on someone's personal phone,
- the fact that the wiping behaviour isn't already clearly illegal with horrific penalties, or
- the idea that the kind of employee waiver mentioned in the article might actually be considered a fair and enforceable part of any employment contract.
This is just so completely wrong, it's hard to know where to start!
- maukdaddy 16y agoIf you put sensitive company data on your phone, you have consented to this behavior. Some companies make it an explicit acceptance, others implicit. If you don't like this kind of thing, use a DIFFERENT phone for work and personal. As an example. You use your phone for company business and have sensitive data on customers, including payment info, birth dates, addresses, socials, etc. If your company knows this data exists on your phone, they have a LEGAL obligation to wipe that data in certain circumstances.
- Silhouette 16y ago> If you put sensitive company data on your phone, you have consented to this behavior. Some companies make it an explicit acceptance, others implicit. So allowing any company data onto your phone is not only consent but implicit consent to the company arbitrarily wiping your entire phone? I'm with the guy in the original article: I would love to see you make that argument with a straight face while standing before a judge in court. I imagine the consequences would be... expensive.
- maukdaddy 16y agoI hope you're joking. Too lazy to look right now, but I'm pretty sure legal precedence for this is already established. If you read almost every company's AUP you'll see that by using or connecting to their systems you are consenting and giving up your right to privacy.
- Silhouette 16y ago> Too lazy to look right now, but I'm pretty sure legal precedence for this is already established. Unfortunately, so far, exactly no-one responding to my original comment has managed to provide even a specific statement of what they think the law requires an employer to do in this context, never mind any verifiable citations. And yet, several different posters claim that there is some form of legal obligation on an employer that not only justifies but actively requires them to have this kind of facility to do it. What legal obligation do you all think a company has to be able to destroy an employee's personal data arbitrarily? What precedent do you think has been established, and in what jurisdiction? > If you read almost every company's AUP you'll see that by using or connecting to their systems you are consenting and giving up your right to privacy. Companies say all kinds of things in agreements. Many of them are completely one-sided, some to the extent of being abusive of an employer-employee relationship. Fortunately, given that many of them are imposed without any real scope for negotiation, courts tend to rule that the unreasonable ones are not enforceable. Those conditions that interfere with an employee's life outside of work are among the most commonly struck down; see the status of overly broad non-compete clauses in many US states or most of Europe, for example.
- tptacek 16y agoThere's nothing wrong about it at all; it's a completely reasonable due-diligence security mechanism. First and most importantly, employers cannot remote-wipe your phone if you haven't paired it with their Exchange infrastructure. Remote-wipe is part of the technical contract you enter into when you link your phone to your company's internal infrastructure. Therefore, while it's totally reasonable to be outraged at the prospect of your employer wiping your phone, the answer is simply "don't let them". Why do IT departments need this capability? That's easy: when you synced your phone up to their email system, you collected an unspecified number of company secrets. Some of those secrets come with a legal obligation to safeguard them. In a surprisingly large number of companies, some of those obligations have theoretical criminal penalties attached to them. Turning off your Exchange access doesn't get rid of secrets Exchange disclosed to you already. Companies turn over tens or even hundreds of employees a week. It's absurd to suggest that they'd leave this matter up to chance, with or without a "scrub your device regularly" policy. More to the point: when companies lose PI, PII, or financials, they end up in the newspaper. Usually, when there's even a reasonable likelihood that data has been exposed, companies are required to notify impacted business partners, incurring contractual and legal expenses. Even if you just left the phone in a bar, and the thief is almost certainly just going to wipe the phone anyways. It's naive to suggest that companies accept the risk of landing in the paper or in court every time someone loses a phone. It's also perfectly reasonable to point out (bad) IT departments that require you to tie your personal phone to their email systems. By all means, bring up "remote-wipe" when they refuse to buy you a crappy Blackberry instead of letting you B.Y.O.
- Silhouette 16y ago> There's nothing wrong about it at all; it's a completely reasonable due-diligence security mechanism. Nonsense. There is absolutely nothing diligent about having an ability to wipe someone's personal data that has no connection to your business, under any circumstances. > Remote-wipe is part of the technical contract you enter into when you link your phone to your company's internal infrastructure. Therefore, while it's totally reasonable to be outraged at the prospect of your employer wiping your phone, the answer is simply "don't let them". So, here's Flawed Cliché #1 in the opposition argument: "If you don't like it, don't sign up for it." Unfortunately, if this sort of behaviour is tolerated, it becomes an assumption by management that it is acceptable. Refusing to accept it yourself then gets you a black mark in some manager's mental file, at best. Moreover, the risk to the personal phone here is completely disproportionate. This sort of link could be established by an employee without any awareness of the potential consequences, in response to a casual request by a manager before the employee goes off to a conference the following week. > Why do IT departments need this capability? That's easy: when you synced your phone up to their email system, you collected an unspecified number of company secrets. Some of those secrets come with a legal obligation to safeguard them. Flawed Cliché #2: "You have to protect company secrets." Firstly, this is a complete straw man: protecting company secrets from the company mail server does not in any way require deletion of personal data on a personal phone. Secondly, if the company has legal or regulatory constraints in how it handles some data, it should not be providing access to that data on a system that is not supplied, properly configured and fully secured by the company's experts anyway. > Companies turn over tens or even hundreds of employees a week. It's absurd to suggest that they'd leave this matter up to chance, with or without a "scrub your device regularly" policy. Flawed Cliché #3: "We need to secure our data when people leave to protect us against inside jobs." Firstly, anyone who is pulling off an inside job is probably not going to leave the only copy of valuable/sensitive data on their personal phone. Secondly, maybe you should be more careful with who you hire if this is a serious problem. Someone who is determined to pull off an inside job isn't going to be stopped by such a simplistic approach. Basically, your entire counter-argument is a non-argument. Nothing you have said in any way justifies a company having the power to interfere with your personal data, and if they need that kind of power over company data because of its sensitivity then they should not be relying on employees' own devices anyway.
- ghurlman 16y agoHere's where: If you don't want to give your company any control of your phone, refuse to use it for work.
- jodrellblank 16y agoThis is just so completely wrong, it's hard to know where to start! You could start by not being a panicky reactionary mess about it. It is useful to be able to wipe a remote mobile device with access into a company computer system when it it is lost, compromised or in unfriendly hands. From that follows that software developers made it possible and providers made it available and employers think it reasonable to use on any mobile device which agreed to access their servers, personal or not. It isn't illegal with "horrific penalties" - why would it be?
- Silhouette 16y ago> It isn't illegal with "horrific penalties" - why would it be? This whole discussion is about a company wiping an employee's personal phone, by accident and for no reason, including cutting off an active call and disrupting the navigation system they were using. Do you really not see why this behaviour is unacceptable?
- jodrellblank 16y agoI really do not see why this behaviour is unacceptable. It cannot be unacceptable to have accidents. Or, you can choose to not accept it if you like but they will still happen. This was not a serious accident like a poisoning due to dodgy food labelling or a car crash or a bulldozer knocking her house down, and therefore it does not require legislation and it certainly does not require "horrific pentalties".
- Silhouette 16y agoBy your argument, should we not also abolish crimes such as manslaughter and causing death by careless driving, not permit any legal actions based on negligence, and generally absolve everyone of any responsibility for their actions even if those actions are both harmful and avoidable provided that they are not deliberate? If that is your position, then we have very different ethics here. > This was not a serious accident Several people in this discussion seem to bring that up, but as far as I can see we don't know either way. It is certainly possible that the same action could have caused loss of much personal data of sentimental and/or direct financial value, cut off communications at an important moment with all kinds of serious consequences, left a driver stranded with no navigation to get them back to familiar territory, etc. Even if that didn't happen in this particular case, it was pure luck.