3 ms·
>Prof Strumia analysed papers available in a database of particle physics research. He produced a series of graphs which, he claimed, showed that women were hir
by duxup 8y ago
>Prof Strumia analysed papers available in a database of particle physics research. He produced a series of graphs which, he claimed, showed that women were hired over men whose research was cited more by other scientists in their publications, which is an indication of higher quality.
>He also presented data that he claimed showed that male and female researchers were equally cited at the start of their careers but men scored progressively better as their careers progressed.
I know being published and cited is a big deal in those fields, but is that really a great measuring stick? Couldn't those choices be filled with any sort of bias, or just picking things that support a common theory or line of thinking... and not indicate quality?
It seems like a potentially poor benchmark.
- Barrin92 8y agoYes, it is completely circular. Because if discrimination against women exists, then the higher citation rate and slower career progress are equally explained by this. This isn't evidence in favour of some causal explanation about innate differences between men and women, he's just trying to justify his prior assumptions. This is very much comparable to the circular nature of IQ measurement. People with racist attitudes often conflate innate ability and IQ, because IQ is very much designed to measure the sort of things that people who like IQ tests are good at. These people will often present evidence in the same way the physicist does, by pointing out that say, people with higher IQs have higher personal income, but this obviously neglects the facts that if IQ tests / degrees etc.. are licenses for success in the first place, so you're just running in circles.
- toasterlovin 8y agoIQ tests are not used as barriers to any institutions in the US (or in most of the developed world). They are almost exclusively used for research purposes.
- 0815test 8y agoIQ tests have been used as barriers in some circumstances - for example, people who are "too smart" may be at a disadvantage should they want to enter some police forces in the U.S.
- lawnchair_larry 8y agoThat was my thinking on this metric as well. From an outsider’s perspective, it seems like quite a stretch to suggest that influence is a relevant metric for skill. There is likely a loose correlation, sure, but unless I’m missing something, it seems only slightly better than throwing dice.