4 ms·
>> He also showed cartoons deriding women campaigning for equality in science and presented the results of an analysis that he claimed showed that work conducte
by YeGoblynQueenne 8y ago
>> He also showed cartoons deriding women campaigning for equality in science and presented the results of an analysis that he claimed showed that work conducted by female physicists was not as good as their male counterparts.
My underlined sentence, is most likely the reason Cern considered that Alessandro Strumia's actions would bring disrepute to the Centre. Holding and publicly discussing controversial views is one thing. Publicly ridiculing your colleagues is quite another.
- deleted 8y ago[deleted]
- zarkov99 8y agoDid you see the slides in question? If not take a look: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1c_NyUhOZ8erdqU2AGZJZtNfFeA91Kefj/view https://drive.google.com/file/d/1c_NyUhOZ8erdqU2AGZJZtNfFeA9... I see no great insults here, one cartoon suggests that the gender studies activists that are so concerned about the lack of women in STEM could have better addressed the problem if they themselves pursued careers in STEM rather than gender studies. The other cartoon is even milder. As to ridiculing his colleagues, from what I can see there is one slide in which Strumia states a female colleague that was hired over him has 10x fewer citations. Assuming that is true, how is that ridiculing a colleague?
- YeGoblynQueenne 8y agoYes, I've seen the slides. They are offensive and the cartoons in them are offensive in the context of the slides. There is no question that they would harm CERN's repuation and that people at CERN would be livid at Strumio's talk as a result.
- mrjesus 8y ago"Offence is taken and not given". They are obviously jokes to illustrate a point. The fact that you call them offensive instead of attacking the criticism itself is fuelling the push back against you and it is continuously mounting. I have seen people's careers and spoken to countless others because people took offence over basically nothing or flat out lined to ruin someone. Men now are actively just avoiding women at work whenever possible if they are smart. Precisely because of this offence culture. In the UK we have people going to prison for being "offensive" this can be anything from jokes in poor taste to legitimate political speech. https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-merseyside-43816921 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-merseyside-43816921 https://www.spiked-online.com/2019/02/27/chelsea-russell-and-the-depravity-of-pc/ https://www.spiked-online.com/2019/02/27/chelsea-russell-and...
- SiempreViernes 8y agoHe is saying ”you got hired despite being dumb, and the girl that hired you was dumb too!”, which is clearly what he is implying given the context of the talk itself and that nice conspirational quote he put underneath. I find it remarkable that you can read that slide, where he insults the selection comitte by proxy and one of its female members directly, and not come to the conclusion that he is correctly being kicked out. What would it take to count as bad? A specific death threat with his signature underneath, or would his citation count balance that out too, as long as the wording is mild?
- lawnchair_larry 8y agoHe didn’t publicly ridicule anyone. His comics are not offensive, and I found them to be pretty on point.
- leereeves 8y agoThat's an excellent point that reminds me of the article that was recently on Hacker News: Our Culture of Contempt. https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/02/opinion/sunday/political-polarization.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/02/opinion/sunday/political-... He could have handled this more professionally. But at the risk of committing a "motive attribution error" myself, it seems clear that that standard is being selectively applied; even the CERN staff who filmed a fake human sacrifice and released the video to the public were never publicly outted. If Strumia were wrong, he would be no threat. He'd just be ignored or disproven. He's dangerous because he's speaking an inconvenient truth, and thus a real threat to certain people's agenda, and so he must be silenced and publicly excoriated, pour encourager les autres.
- cbx101 8y agoThe general problem is that in academia the administrations are too large and staffed with the wrong people who have to fight these battles in order to justify their existence. Human groups always degrade into Animal Farm (obviously with varying degrees of severity), where a caste of administrators rules the productive class.
- SiempreViernes 8y agoNo, it is the insulting of named members of the selection comitte that didn’t hire him that is almost the entirety of the problem.
- leereeves 8y agoYour theory is that the whole reason for firing him was that he insulted CERN management? That's an interesting theory, but it certainly makes the CERN management look petty.