3 ms·
Ugh, the USPTO is getting really nasty here. If you actually read the proposed rules, they amount to saying "if the Supreme Court hasn't specifically ruled that
by jcranmer 8y ago
Ugh, the USPTO is getting really nasty here. If you actually read the proposed rules, they amount to saying "if the Supreme Court hasn't specifically ruled that the matter is patent-ineligible, then we should assume it is patent-eligible," which is a very myopic view of how SCOTUS has consistently ruled on patentability in the past decade.
Of course, the real problem here isn't the USPTO, it's the Federal Circuit. The Federal Circuit's decisions are binding precedent unless overruled by the Supreme Court, and the Federal Circuit has pretty consistently followed the test being cited in the guidelines, so USPTO has to follow. This is despite SCOTUS constantly telling the Federal Circuit that they have it utterly wrong on patentability; they just haven't gotten the message yet.
- holy_city 8y ago>This is despite SCOTUS constantly telling the Federal Circuit that they have it utterly wrong on patentability; they just haven't gotten the message yet. The remedy there is for SCOTUS to make definitive rulings, is it not?
- WillPostForFood 8y agoThe ideal remedy is for Congress to update the patent law.
- _rpd 8y agoMy understanding is that the Fed Circuit rulings were very inconsistent, so that for every patent claim there was a ruling saying it was eligible and another saying it was ineligible, with the eligibility possibly changing every time a new ruling came out. The new guidelines are intended to establish a clear procedure that can be applied consistently.