3 ms·
Doesn't this boil down to an even more specific version of an 'anthropic principle' argument with a good deal of sampling bias added and easier-to-spot problems
by pvg 8y ago
Doesn't this boil down to an even more specific version of an 'anthropic principle' argument with a good deal of sampling bias added and easier-to-spot problems? For instance, there's no reason to assume the only way to get a long-term, stable-enough environment for the development of intelligent life is precisely a planetary system with a gas giant (why does it have to be a gas giant?) and a rocky inner planet with a chonker of a satellite.
- reallydude 8y agogas giants dont eject material as often and tend to be large gravity wells because thats the defining characteristic that maintains cohesion? (giant)
- pvg 8y agoAs often as what? Plus, we've seen some pretty huge rocky planets. Another way of looking this is that it's akin to erroneously calculating the probability that someone might win the lottery twice by multiplying 1/gazillion by 1/gazillion and concluding it can't realistically ever happen.
- btilly 8y agoThis is a version of an anthropic principle argument. However it is not arbitrary, and not an assumption. When you run simulations you can test different combinations of factors and see what difference they make. See, for example, https://www.space.com/31577-earth-life-jupiter-saturn-giant-impacts.html https://www.space.com/31577-earth-life-jupiter-saturn-giant-... to see how important gas giants are for blocking large impacts on small rocky inner planets. That said, there may be another way to get long-term stability. But if so, then we haven't found it. And yes, we've looked.
- pvg 8y agoand not an assumption. What do you mean? 'You have to replicate the solar system to come up with intelligent life' is a gigantic assumption, on top of the 'solar system-like planetary system are rare' assumption. Is this a conceivable narrative for the Fermi paradox? Sure. But it's hardly supported enough to make a reasonable probabilistic argument out of it.
- btilly 8y agoWhat I mean is this. The statements "a large moon makes the axial tilt stable" and "a gas giant greatly reduces how many comets hit small rocky worlds in a solar system" are both verifiable. They are not assumptions. We also have reasonably compelling evidence that both factors are important for intelligent life to arise. Or, more precisely, good reason to believe that extreme axial tilts and cometary impacts are really, really bad for the biosphere. So the importance of those factors is itself not exactly arbitrary.
- pvg 8y agoYou can definitely narrow the Fermi paradox to 'earth-like life' so you can at least attempt to make some sort of estimate. That's reasonable. What's not reasonable is saying this huge assumption is not an assumption. It's totally an assumption, even if it's an assumption you are making because without it, there is even less to say.
- namanyayg 8y agoThere are significantly fewer planets that have gas giants around compared to the ones that don't. It it certain that gas giants prevent debris attacking small rocky planets. It is obviously an assumption other intelligent life will be like us, we do not know of any other intelligent life to be able to say otherwise. But if I'm looking for life, especially intelligent life, I will look for planets having conditions similar to ours. This is because our sample size is just one, us. It could be that NOT having gas giants around is how intelligent life ACTUALLY exists in 99.99% of the cases of intelligent life in the milky way galaxy and Earth is the 0.01%. But if I have looked a lot and still just have Earth to guess with, I will continue looking for Earth-like planets. There is no way for me to actually know, but I don't want to waste my time.
- pvg 8y agoThere are significantly fewer planets that have gas giants around compared to the ones that don't. It it certain that gas giants prevent debris attacking small rocky planets. I don't think we know the former and we kind of sort of maybe know the latter for the Solar system right now. As to the rest, I don't follow the relevance, we're not talking about searching for intelligent life at all.