3 ms·
I first read about this on Boing Boing[1], which said Manning believes that "since testimony before grand juries is secret, grand juries can create fear by sugg
by pmoriarty 8y ago
I first read about this on Boing Boing[1], which said Manning believes that "since testimony before grand juries is secret, grand juries can create fear by suggesting that some members of a political community may be secretly cooperating with the government. In this way, grand juries can seed suspicion and fear in activist communities."
I'm not sure how not being in a grand jury absolves activists from suspicions of secretly cooperating with the government, because one doesn't need to be in a grand jury to secretly cooperate with the government. In fact, if secrecy in cooperation was paramount, then participating in a grand jury would seem to be counterproductive to maintaining such secrecy.
Later, the article states:
"By serving Chelsea Manning with a grand jury subpoena, the government is attempting once again to punish an outspoken whistleblower for her historic disclosures. We stand with Chelsea in support of her refusal to participate in this repressive and undemocratic process.
"Grand juries are notoriously mired in secrecy, and have historically been used to silence and retaliate against political activists. The indiscriminate nature of grand juries means the government can attempt to artificially coerce a witness into perjury or contempt. Chelsea gave voluminous testimony during her court martial. She has stood by the truth of her prior statements, and there is no legitimate purpose to having her rehash them before a hostile grand jury."
If Manning is willing to testify truthfully and publicly on the subject, then I'm not sure how participating in a grand jury would expose her to either perjury or contempt. It's only if she lied or refused to testify that she could be charged with perjury or contempt, right? But she's not refusing to testify altogether and is not saying she's going to lie, so where does the purjury and contempt worry come from?
Finally, why does the statement refer to a "hostile grand jury"? How is a grand jury hostile?
[1] - https://boingboing.net/2019/03/03/chelsea-resists.html https://boingboing.net/2019/03/03/chelsea-resists.html