3 ms·
As it is a Doctor's time is scarce, which is why systems like this exist in the first place I imagine. One wonders if expecting them to be comforting when deliv
by AnIdiotOnTheNet 8y ago
As it is a Doctor's time is scarce, which is why systems like this exist in the first place I imagine. One wonders if expecting them to be comforting when delivering bad news, or taking the time to explain things properly to a patient, is realistic. After all, even though this is one of the most important events in the patient's life, to the doctor it's tuesday.
I sometimes wonder if the patient demand for "bedside manner" has led to having doctors with less actual medical skill. I mean, I wouldn't choose my mechanic based on how comforting they could be. I wouldn't even choose my veterinarian on that criteria. One could argue that doctors are all roughly equal in diagnosis and prescription I suppose, making bedside manner the only real differentiation, but my personal experience is that that isn't true.
Maybe a different person should be handling the role of interacting with the patient in these ways, Someone who can take the time to do it properly? I don't know. I just think it is worth reconsidering how this works in today's world.
- zentiggr 8y agoI'd say a mechanic's manner is almost off topic... anything mechanical ranks far far below life and death notifications. But I do get why you included them in the comparison. I would want my vet (and so far HAVE had my vets) be even more compassionate than my own doctor. I know enough to talk at least basic jargon with my PCP and specialists as needed. None of my animals has been able to communicate about their trouble, and have relied on that extra bit of comfort and care when they are terminal, or even just very ill. Again, personal preference.
- Balgair 8y ago>I mean, I wouldn't choose my mechanic based on how comforting they could be. I grew up in an auto-shop in the SF Bay, my family still owns one of them. You may not choose a mechanic based on their empathy, but the large majority (~90%) of people do. Trust is a thing that is hard to establish, but incredibly easy to break. One bad part, one snippy phone call, will totally ruin the relationship that you've built up over decades with a customer and their family. They'll never walk in the door again. We've experimented with all forms of customer communication. From texts, to online booking, to Groupon and Yelp. Nothing works anywhere near as good as an inperson chat. When you've got to deliver the message that their car needs a $3k new transmission, despite the family road-trip in a week's time, it's best to do it face to face. Most of the time, that's not realistic, so a phone call is the next best thing. When the estimate is high like that, then it usually takes over 10 minutes per call. There's a lot of yelling and crying, usually. People get very attached to their cars. Hell, they'll abandon their house and home before they abandon their cars[0]. When you do extensive surgery on the car they drove their new wife home in, that they drove their first-born in, that they cried in when their Mom died, that they spilled innumerable sodas in, well, you can understand why they throw money into the repairs even when it makes no sense. Providing that 'deft hand', those years of knowledge and experience, has helped the business not just survive the Dot-Com and Housing crashes, but has let us thrive despite those economic catastrophes. Knowing how to tell someone that the car is no longer worth the repair does take some experience and care. Customers have come to trust us in helping them make decisions they have a hard time with. The majority of what trust is made of, what it can be partitioned out into, is empathy. [0] one reason I'm not bullish on self driving car services that are all rentals and leases.