3 ms·
x86 has been the RISCiest of the CISC architectures I agree completely if you mean "RISCiest" as in the complexity of decoding instructions. Look at the opcode
by userbinator 8y ago
x86 has been the RISCiest of the CISC architectures
I agree completely if you mean "RISCiest" as in the complexity of decoding instructions. Look at the opcode map of a VAX, for example --- instructions were simply added where they fit, so there's no easily discernable pattern in the bits of the first opcode byte. x86 has an octal structure to its instructions[1] and the first quarter of the opcode map (000 through 077 octal) contains nearly all the commonly used ALU operations.
The 8086 along with the Z80 and its predecessors had to be implemented on a single chip, which put constraints on how complex its instruction encoding could be, which could explain why a regular structure (but not fixed length) was adopted instead of a more "true CISC" way of making every instruction opcode arbitrarily increasing and microcoding everything.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9322723 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9322723